In a publishing universe of almost completely subjective waffle without facts I like JA's measurements and graphs. I have learned to read his prose very carefully, and ignore the commercial talk. The amplifier measurements with a simulated real load are particularly revealing, I find. Fortunately there are a few other international publications with fact based reviews. |
@Koost_amojan You are correct. The cost of the speaker is no reflection on the quality - especially the tweeter. The Excel Millenium Sonotex soft done tweeter has the best waterfall I have seen. It is expensive at around 200 euros per unit and therefore very few manufacturers use it. Since most speakers are fairly good in frequency response the waterfall plot plot is far and above the most important speaker measurement. Another key plot is the dispersion horizontally. Unfortunately not many folks understand the importance. |
@bar81 +1 Exactly how I read JA last paragraph. Full of euphemistic BS whenever the POS SOTA ultra expensive audio jewellry measured performance is poor in certain aspects. He is also careful not to compare products and be overly enthusiastic when performance in a reasonable price product is exceptional - usually just saying he is impressed. After all a reviewing magazine needs advertising revenue and cooperation from the industry - so it can't pick winners and it's job is to cheer on every latest product. So kudos that JA still manages to convey his views to those who are discerning enough to translate that last paragraph. |
I'm sorry, did we want to talk about the price of speakers, or their sound quality? I'm confused. As I've written, JA loves speakers that sound like hearing aids. If that's what you like, feel free. https://speakermakersjourney.blogspot.com/2016/05/stereophile-reviews-data-doesnt-lie.html Best, E |
@erik_squires LOL The author is entirely correct about smiley EQ curve speakers with the standard industry midrange scoop ....however this is INDUSTRY WIDE - you can hardly blame Stereophile or JA for what consumers want and buy in huge quantities. Junk food is bad for you too but people love it and but it in large quantity! This has been called mid scoop or BBC dip but it is highly prevalent - B&W dominate this style sound. If you don’t like industry standard smiley EQ (presumably because you don’t yet need hearing aids) then get ATC which are flat (but actually sound midrange forward compared to most everything else.) |
