2. tech-talk
  3. 983207388

Blind Listening Tests?

I would like help locating any articles or studies on the subject of blind listening tests as it relates to high end audio equipment. I realize this is akin to blasphemy for many who are into this hobby, however, the more times I read of people claiming to hear audible differences between certain components and system set-ups, the more skeptical I become.(e.g. equipment racks ,interconnects,etc.)The fact that virtually every major audio publication is so adamently against the idea only adds to my skepticism.

Before I invoke the wrath of this site's faithful, let me clarify that I am not doubting the sincerity of those who claim to hear sonic differences between certain components. However, believing that an audible difference exists when one knows that he is listening to a piece of equipment that is generally well regarded or made by a well respected manufacturer is entirely different from being able to detect the difference in a blind listening scenario. Given the undisputed connection between the mind and our perceptions, why is there so much sentiment against such tests? Couldn't the results of such testing be simply another piece of information that we could factor in to our purchasing decisions. It seems to me that those who are so sure of ther critical listening ability (i.e. all stereophile reviewers) should not hesitate to prove their skills.

I look forward to any help in directing me to more information on the subject.Thanks, Don.
dtittle
70242241e18c
81 posts
 
Jadem6: Your imagination is running amok. I never said there could never be any difference in performance between pieces of audio gear.

Detlof: You're right, I'm no drummer. I'd be the engineer in the control room. ;)
detlof
1,899 posts
 
702 thanks for your clever and witty response. Nice to have you on board, though we often disagree. But that makes life interesting.
ebarker2
64 posts
 
There is a german psychologists study of 3 audio systems blind tested to more than 50 members of the public. Very interesting, the trouble is I can't remember which web site I read it on. Might be linked through audio asylum, or audionove.

Blind tests are complex, not just because some of the differences are percieved over time, and in ways which are difficult if not impossible to articulate.

As far as your scepticism of some refinements, I was too, but you can hear differences clearly if you exagerate. If you have biwireable speakers, wire the bass with ordinary shopping mall quality wire, and the highs with a decent audiograde. Then reverse the two. The difference should be easily heard.
More to discover