Rega Saturn or Sony SCD-XA5400ES ?


Hi Mates,
Which one is a better player for stand alone Red Book CD play and just as a transport ? I am looking for full body, high resolution, smooth, organic, low noise and crystal clear sound. Any experinece, comparioson or advice will be highly appreciated. Thanks,
topmostaudio
I have a Sony SCD-XA5400ES running single ended with Nordost SPM cables which I like very much. I don't know which model Rega I have heard at the dealer when auditioning speakers but I preferred the Sony.
Is the Sony SCD-XA5400ES really an over-achiever? Has anyone compared it to much more expensive CD playback?
The UK mag Hi-Fi Choice (Jan 2010 issue) has done a comparison of several CD players including the Sony 5400ES. In contrast to the comments I read in this forum, they gave the Sony a good, but not outstanding review. They praised the midtrange but described a "slight lack of precision in bass and treble". The Creek Destiny, Moon CD3.3 & Shanling CD-R1000se all got better ratings. Based on general comments, HFC also appear to rate the Rega Saturn more highly than the Sony.