SME V Tonearm on eBay Hong Kong Sellers are FAKE!!!


These scumbags have been selling these for a while now. It comes from multiple accounts originating out of Hong Kong. They sell on average two SME V tonearms a month, at $1400-$2200, auction style. Fellow audiophiles, please stop buying these. They are 100% fake. They are cheap hideous copies.

Report and do not buy from sellers: mandy-930 and makiyo2008
invictus005
Copy, Replica, Recreation.....they are all FAKE and COUNTERFEIT.   No amount of sophistry will change that.  I would go so far as to say one man's "copy...in the sense of admiration" is another man's theft of property.

Regarding something as critical as a tonearm, I would wonder about the quality of the materials used in construction.  What is the quality of the bearing(s) ?   Different base metals, or composites, machined to a standard that is not the same as the original, bearings of inferior grade...all would combine to represent an inferior product.  Just because it "looks" the same, does not mean it will perform the same.....

Given that the seller(s) are in HK leads me to believe that the producer of the arm(s) is Chinese based.   Another red flag.   This is not a xenophobic judgment but a caveat based upon known trade practices.    How many times have we seen Chinese based components at shockingly low prices that look a lot like a known brand ?  

As for the SME Arm, individuals complaining to Ebay may not accomplish anything.   I would complain to the local importer, and parent company, then let their lawyers contact Ebay regarding FAKE and COUNTERFEIT merchandise.

Ebay and/or PayPal protection is based on buyers money. The

money can be blocked on sellers account and in case of

''default'' returned to the buyer. The general complaint is ''not

as described'' ( in the listing). This obviously apply for items which

are described as ''original'' but are in fact copies. The difference

between SME and FR-B-60 is that the later is described as ''copy''.

I think that B-60 is much more easy to ''reproduce'' with modern

CNN lathe's than SME. Even so the B-60 replica could not be sold

for more than $500 . That is why those are not anymore produced.

The seller was not able to get any profit with this price.

BTW intellectual property is protected for certain time while the

precondition is payment of ''maintenance'' contribution . The added

problem is that patent law in one country is not the same as in

the other. I think that fashion has much problems with ''replicas''

than objects of our desire.


I am not sure about the US, but here in Europe selling counterfeit goods is a crime, and so is taking them across borders or even buying them.