Which speaker is better

Just me 2 cents... I love the Guarnieri Homage... I find the B&W not enough revealing... Of course this is to my taste...

Also, you should describe the electronics you will be using. It may be easier to give some advice...

Note: I don't own any of those speakers...

It depends on what you like to listen to. If it's music, the Sonus Faber. IMHO

duh...