Music Server vs Computer?


Currently streaming music from a PC to a modded Airport Express that's connected to my pre. The Wyred4Sound music server looks really inviting. Appears to do everything my PC does. Ripping cds sounds like a breeze and storage capacity is great (1T or 2T). All I have to do is link it with a DAC. Are there any disadvantages, to include SQ, to using a music server vs using a PC/MAC? Seems to me that they both use HDs for storage, but that SQ with the MS might be better because streaming is eliminated.
rockyboy
The problem with most servers is that they force you into using FLAC, they don't import .wav files etc.. Lack of flexibility. They are mostly compromised for SQ due to either poor ripping software, poor playback software or both.

There are some exceptions however:

The Antipodes server from New Zealand has none of these limitations and is the only server I have found that sounds identical playing FLAC and wav files.

The Bryston server is also excellent and has few limitations.

I have heard both or had them in my room at trade shows.

I personally use a tweaked Oct 2009 Mac Mini powered with a Hynes supply with Amarra playback software. This is world-class.

Steve N.
Empirical Audio
I am a fan of the Baetis Audio Revelation II (baetisaudio.com) server; just purchased it and love it. It buys its chassis from the same Australian company that Antipodes does but the design and build quality blows the Antipode away. Do not assume they are the same internally because they look the same. Baetis has done much research on the sound of different mother boards and tested several through a Wilson system and could hear the differences. It is the first server to take the sound right from the board via BNC. They started with the mother board and built enough computer around it for software etc. 8 USB ports for external Hard drives and Toslink, BNC out, etc., all galvanically isolated. An internal 128G solid state memory; 16G of RAM. Check it out. Extremely quiet; compact and powerful. You will hear more about this unit after the review forthcoming the beginning of next year! Reviewers and computer audio fans will finally realize just hooking up any computer doesn't produce the best computer audio has to offer.
I suspect the Baetis is higher priced and should be based on the extra effort and build quality put into the Revelation. Check the web site: www.baetisaudio.com and give the designers a call for a more technical explanation.
I second the comments on the Baetis. I have been using it in my system and against my APL two box digital (which includes an Esoteric transport) it is very impressive and holds its own although I still haven't done extensive comparisons as of yet. Great build quality, dbpoweramp for ripping and JRiver for playback. John at Baetis has also been superb in terms of customer service - some of the best service I've had post purchase.