I would add:
Use sellers who have some 'threads' and 'answers' on various subjects in addition to sales feedback.
They are far more likely to be 'audiophiles' selling stuff they used, rather than stuff someone found at a rummage sale, or a friend of a friend owned.
TTs ARE hard to ship without damage... same for large speakers and over 75 lb chunks of amplifier. For these things you need to be extra cautious. Double boxing in 2" or better dense foam is the trick.
Old Cd players CAN be a good deal, if you stick to top end major brand players. Pioneer Elite, Sony ES ... old hi-end major brand players are built like a tank, and I can say from experience, they can last for 70,000 playing hrs or more! (Sony ES 89, ditto CD9ES)
Dead brands are a chancey thing (Counterpoint) They can be a great item, but repair is difficult unless (like Counterpoint) they have a special aftermarket repair/upgrade center.
Phono cartridges are the hardest thing to buy used. They can be a wonderful deal, or a ripoff. All depends on the seller.
Cables can also be a great deal... But I would avoid the higher priced ones from non-retail dealers... Only because the chance for a fake is too great.
Cheaper ones that have a distinct design like Nordost Blue Heaven or Red Dawn.. Or KimberKable PBJ are fine. Or Kimber with the wood block on the cordset. (they are not easily faked.) Ditto high priced power cords.
And for cords and connectors ALWAYS buy with the original box!
(Obviously this advice is for a beginner! These expensive connectors and cords can be bought and sold safely, but you better know what your doing to buy them!!!)
Buy only stuff that has the original box, and manual. This stuff is far more likely to be from a first buyer with a bigger home. (places to store the boxes.) Stuff without boxes is way more likely to be second hand store, passed down through several hands stuff (Again this is for a newbi buyer. I would use my judgement on this if I was buying something...
Avoid buying from the Hurricane states coastal areas. Avoid out of country (just for problems if any extra problems arise!)