What's with 4 ohm speakers?


If 4 ohm speakers are harder to drive, why do manufacturers keep coming out with them?
50jess
Jjrenman, you are absolutely correct. People commonly assume that Efficiency and Sensitivity are the same but that is only true into exactly 8 ohms.
Finally got around to that test I mentioned earlier.

So I built a single test speaker with 5 individually sealed Dayton DS135-8's (5"). Not normally a choice for a sealed enclosure but fairly conventional except for a high Qms,low volume requirement and low price. These are nominal 8 ohm rated drivers. They were arranged vertically with 9 inches center to center and a 9 inch wide baffle. That approximates a typical MTM setup but without the T. I kept the volume and the microphone fixed. This is an Omnimic USB microphone. I tested with both "pseudo-noise" and short sine sweeps and measured max SPL. The amp used was a bridged Plinius SA-100.

For a starting point, I measured a single driver at 78 dB C weighted. (+- 0.1 dB for either test)

Two in parallel (4 ohms) measured +4 dB higher than a single. A touch lower on the short sine sweep.

Two in series (16 ohms) measured -1.5 dB lower than a single.

Four in parallel/series (8 ohms) measured +1.7 dB higher than a single. In earlier tests with this setup, I did notice a comb filtering effect and a dip around 1 KHz at the same mic location.

Won't draw any conclusions but I encourage anybody else to try a similar experiment. Results do go against standard convention. With closer spacing, or other factors, results may vary.

This test speaker was for more than just this. It also proved that I would need five of these drivers in a parallel/series 2.5-way setup to achieve some BSC and a fairly flat in-room response.
Won't draw any conclusions but I encourage anybody else to try a similar experiment. Results do go against standard convention. With closer spacing, or other factors, results may vary.

Actually this sounds pretty predictable to me. The Plinius can double power when impedance is halved, so it would make 3 db more output. Depending on where the mic is placed, you will find out about beaming and line source effect as well.

If you ran the same tests with a tube amp you would get different readings- likely more output with the drivers in series rather than parallel.