Best Budget Phono Cartridge?


After upgrading my system for CDs and SACDs recently, I pulled my old turntable out of storage to see how it would stack up. It sounded pretty sick, and my best guess is that an old (very old) Stanton 681EEE is the culprit. I don’t want to spend a lot of money on this experiment, but if I can find a decent cartridge in the $100-250 range it would be fun to see how my old vinyl compares. I’m looking at the following new or NOS cartridges:


Audio Technica AT7V MM or AT-F2 MC

Denon DL 103 MC or DL 110 MC;

Grado Prestige Gold1

Sumiko Pearl MM  

Ortofon 2M Blue MM  

Shure M97xE

 Would any of you like to weigh in on this list, or add a favorite of your own? I’ll be inputing to a Parasound New Classic 2100 preamp.


cheeg

From the looks of it a medium to low mass arm. I would suggest a Nagaoka 110 as a fantastic cartridge. Another approach, since the 681 is such a fine performer, is to get a new stylus for it from JICO.

Would suggest that, since you are unable to adjust vertical tracking angle, elliptical or conical stylii will be better than line contact stylii which you may not be able to align correctly, which would put the 440 out, although AT makes nice cartridges and you might try one with an elliptical stylus, whatever the current version is that is comparable to the 120E.

Thanks viridian -- I had heard that replacement styluses for the 681 were not worth it, as the body doesn't age well; have you heard otherwise?

Regarding the VTA, you are right that the turntable doesn't have an adjustment, but I thought that could be done either at the cartridge head or platten.  Is that a bad idea?

Also, thanks for the Nagaoka 110 suggestion; I'll look into it.

Most of the stuff that you read on the net is total crap - particularly the stuff that I write. But there are lots of threads about the eee and I don’t see any that have issues with body ageing (though I have this problem with my body), a recent one:

http://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/stanton-681eee-nos-or-replacement-stylus.788696/

But no, I have not owned one since they were new, which probably goes a long way to explaining my body ageing thing. So I can’t speak to ageing in this specific cartridge, though I do have a couple of very old 500s and two Pickering XV15s that seem fine as well. 

Aligning a cartridge without VTA provided by the arm is easy if you are looking for negative VTA, raising the front of the arm up. You can do this with thin cardboard circles under the mat, or a thicker mat, or a million other ways.

But if you need positive VTA, if the back of the arm needs to go upward you are now going to be canting the cartridge by putting something between the headshell and the front top of the cartridge. This method also causes most of the cartridge body not to be in contact with the headshell giving up some of the damping qualities inherent in an intimate contact. The other possibility would be finding a thinner mat, if that would create enough of a change to get you to the correct height, and not change the damping of the platter itself a significant amount.

Neither method is particularly amenable to very fine adjustment of VTA though, however, as you point out, it is more than possible given enough time and patience. I have done it many times, but can’t really recommend it.



What a great thread on Stanton 681 replacements -- thanks viridian!  One of my concerns (in addition to that body ageing thing, with which I totally relate), was that the JICO replacement stylus is $167, and I didn't see any point in spending that much $ to resuscitate a cartridge body that may not be in such good shape.   But if the author of the thread is right, it sounds like the Pfanstiehl 4822-DEE-P is a decent replacement stylus, at only $29 -- that's a no-brainer!  At worst, I can use it as a backup set of "rock skis", for my rutted records that would otherwise tear up good needles.  Thanks, too, for the advice on rough VTR adjustment; if the Phanstiehl doesn't work out, I may yet need to try it.  Or maybe just get a better arm...