50 years on---the brilliance of The Band and their astounding debut album.


There are people who still, fifty years after it’s release on July 1st, 1968, don’t get what all the fuss made about The Band’s debut album, Music From Big Pink, is all about. I understand; I didn’t until a whole year later. It took me that long to figure out "What the heck IS this?" I didn’t get it AT ALL (I had just turned 18, and was still a boy ;-). Here’s what some people who did had to say about it at the time of it’s release:

Al Kooper: "Music From Big Pink is an event and should be treated as one. There are people who will work their whole lives away in vain and not touch it." Eric Clapton admitted as much when, while inducting them into The Rock ’n’ Roll Hall Of Fame, said "I was relieved in a way when they ended. I no longer had to live with the fact that I was not in The Band." Eric had gone to West Saugerties, NY (the town the Big Pink house, not far from Woodstock, was located) after being played Music From Big Pink by George Harrison (whereupon Eric immediately disbanded Cream), intending to ask to join The Band. He never got up the courage, and eventually realized they neither desired nor required his services ;-).

Speaking of George Harrison, during the January 2, 1969 sessions for what became The Beatles sad Get Back/Let It Be album and film (which are painful, for me at least, to listen to and/or watch), he played a new song of his for the boys, "All Things Must Pass" (which we eventually heard on George’s debut album). The song was originally written to be performed in a country-prayer style, which George later said he had imagined as sung by Band drummer Levon Helm.

During the fade-out at the end of The Beatles live performance of "Hey Jude" filmed at Twinkerham Film Studios on September 4th, 1968 and later shown on The David Frost TV show, McCartney quotes lyrics from The Band’s "The Weight" (an indescribably great song), singing "Take a load off Fanny...".

Greil Marcus, in his 1975 book Mystery Train: Images of America in Rock ’n’ Roll Music, wrote: "The richness of Big Pink is in The Band’s ability to contain endless combinations of American popular music without imitating any of them." The Band’s recordings made with Dylan in the basement of Big Pink in 1967 (now known as The Basement Tapes, The Band at the time as The Hawks) are now viewed as the genesis of what is known as Americana music. Ironic, then, that all but drummer Levon Helm are Canadians, recruited one-by one by Arkansas Rockabilly Ronnie Hawkins during his years playing clubs and bars in Canada in the late-50’s/early 60’s.

It’s hard to overstate the impact Music From Big Pink had on musicians of my generation. Everyone I knew, most especially myself, had to start all over, learning to play in the "musical" style of The Band. Gone were the Les Paul’s and Gibson SG’s into Marshall stacks, and double-kick drumsets with half-a-dozen cymbals, replaced with Telecasters into small combo amps (the Fender Deluxe Reverb a particular favorite), and 4-piece drumsets (tuned low and "thumpy", like Levon) with a couple of cymbals. Gone were the long solos and earbleed-inducing volume. In was ensemble playing, great songs, and harmony singing. Workingman’s Dead is an obvious attempt at being The Band (sabotaged by The Grateful Dead’s member’s inability to sing very well), as is Neil Young’s Harvest.

I still listen to Music From Big Pink EVERY SINGLE DAY, and have for years. Music simply does not get any better than this. There is a new, remixed and mastered (mixed by Bob Clearmountain, mastered by Bob Ludwig) release of the album by Capitol on 2-45RPM LP’s and CD, as well as a deluxe boxset with a nice book, prints of pictures taken of The Band by Elliott Landy in 1968, a Blu Ray 24/96 disc of the album, both the LP’s and CD, and a 7" 45 of The Band’s first single, "The Weight"/"I Shall Be Released". If you don’t have the album and want to, I would suggest you get the current Mobile Fidelity LP or SACD instead of this new version. I’m not yet sure about the remix.

128x128bdp24

Showing 13 responses by n80

When I was in high school in the late 70's I was very much into Led Zep and harder type rock. We had a home room teacher who was a bit of an oddball. He would try to get us southern kids riled up by asking us if we thought that God had a sense of humor. A lot of us thought that was very irreverent. And whenever music came up he would always say The Band was the best band in the world, which most of us thought was nuts. He also affirmed that the Band did The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down better than Joan Baez.

It took me a long time to realize that God certainly has a sense of humor, the Band were one of the great bands of all time and the Baez version is awful.

Any recommendations for the best CD recording of Big Pink?
I also noticed that Astral Weeks and MFBP came out the same year....along with a number of other huge albums from various greats.
Wandered into a used record store today. I'm not into vinyl and hope not to get into it any further than I am. I was just thumbing through the albums when I came upon Music from Big Pink. I've always liked The Band and love the movie The Last Waltz but the only thing I've owned is The Band's best hits.

There were two in the rack. Both used. One was $60. I don't know what was so special about it and since I do not have a turntable that will play $60 LPs I got the one for $30....which was ridiculous enough since I don't know what was so special about it either.

I'm looking forward to giving it a spin since I've never paid attention to the less popular tracks on that album.

Also got a copy of Morrison's Tupelo Honey.

Not sure why I'm buying vinyl but it was a well stocked little shop with lots of vintage hi-fi gear in it as well so I wanted to give the guy some business.

slaw and bdp24, I confused about the 'brown' LP. That's the second album right? If that is the case then album I paid $30 for was MFBP not the second album.

The second album I'm more familiar with.I've heard MFBP before but its been a while. Never gave it a close listen. Seemed very weird and a bit inaccessible but I'll give it some time.

For me $30 was too expensive for _any_ LP. Never spent that much on a record in my life but fully understand that good collectible vinyl can sell for huge prices. But, like I said, I wanted to give the guy some business.

Heck, looking for a good used CD recording of Veedon Fleece looks like it is going to cost $25. This hobby is nuts.

slaw, my comments based on current contemporary music pressings are based on dynamic range recordings, not my opinion, taste in music or ability to differentiate SQ. So it has nothing to do with my equipment, level of experience or price aversion.

If a new pressing of an album has an average dynamic range of 6 on a scale of 1-14 that's pretty awful and no level of equipment is likely to resurrect that low of a production value.
bdp24, thanks for the clarification on the two albums. I do not have the brown album yet. Will probably get it on CD soon. Not knowing how to ID albums and such, all I can say is that this pressing of MFBP is SKAO 2955 and is by Capital. SKAO 2955 is engraved in the runoff area and I do not see anything else there but some sort of arrow symbol.

If I've paid too much, shame on me. I didn't do any research.
bdp24 I think Steve is apologizing for me, and to a lesser extent, him, for highjacking your thread.

Steve, I think you are misunderstanding me. In general my comments about vinyl have _nothing_ to do with sound quality. I'm not making any vinyl SQ verses whatever else comparisons. My only references to vinyl SQ have been in regard to measured DR variations. That's it. So experience and level of equipment is not at all relevant to the points I've made.

My issues with vinyl have nothing to do with SQ, just the whole 'ritual' for lack of a better word, the care required, etc. I haven't even suggested that this should put anyone else off. It is just my personal opinion on the matter and I've seen it shared by any number of previously dedicated vinyl fans.

I also don't think that buying a few albums constitutes any sort of contradiction. I often preface that I'm not getting into vinyl simply to indicate that I'm not looking for advice on equipment, special pressings, etc. (One of these days I might....I'm dabbling here.) Sorry if this caused confusion.

If I've crossed a line, you know, like religion, politics, etc, then I apologize. I'll try to tread more lightly in the future.
I kind of feel that way about Van Morrison's Astral Weeks. Very different from his other stuff, high critical acclaim, amazing musical performances by a stellar cast (jazz and studio musicians). And most general Van Morrison fans have never heard it and don't like it when they do. 

I recall not getting MFBP but like I say, on your recommendation and info I'm going to tackle it and see where it goes. Thanks.
Will do, thanks for the tip. Most of the blues that I own are either iTunes or southern sampler CD I get yearly. Blues is an avenue that could take me into vinyl a ways. 
Led Zep's first album was recorded that year but released on 12 Jan 68.

I was only 5 so none of this was on my radar. What a great time to be a music fan (which for me started about 1972).
Yes, typo, thanks. 

I like the blues, particularly delta blues. Not a scholar or collector of blues per se but it resonates with me. Zeppelin copied, stole and expanded on the blues in a way that works for me so I've been a fan since the mid 70s. Robert Plant's picture is graffiti stenciled all over Clarksdale, Mississippi....ground zero for the blues.

But I get why some don't like them. I get why some blues fans don't like them.
I did some research. The MFBP album that I paid $30 for is a 1969 Capital repress so it is fairly early. On Discogs the prices range from $15 to $85 (+ shipping) for this pressing. The reasons for the wide range in price are not clear to me. Some of it seems to hinge on condition of the cover but almost all of them are rated a VG+ or VG++. Mine was rated VG++. SQ is good. A few clicks and pops but would probably benefit from a good cleaning.

All of which is to say that I don’t feel totally ripped off.
It has a red label. Notes said the lime green label was earlier in 69 and the red was later but that they are the same pressing. All the same markings in the run off area (forget actual term).

Discogs indicated that it was a repress. I don't even know what that entails, just saw it there.

I was into the guitar bands in the late 70's when I was exploring 'older' rock music. The Band sounded very quaint and 'down home' to me and I did not appreciate it. I think for many people it took a greater level of maturity to appreciate The Band than some of their contemporaries.