I'm not dreaming - these are great CD copies


I have an out of town friend who's given me some CD-Rs that he's made by simply copying music off of red book CDs. The music quality is extremely good - better than I'm used to hearing from my red book CDs. He's not an audiophile and has no idea what format is being utilized e.g. Lossless, etc.
Question - Can you really improve the quality of music from a red book CD by simply copying to some other format? If so, I'm boxing up all 300 of my CDs and asking my friend to copy make copies for me.
rockyboy

Showing 2 responses by fleschler

My experience burning 10,000s of CDRs for musicians (masters and copies) on an Alesis Masterlink has been that occasionally, the CDRs will sound better than the original pressed CD.  Generally, they sound the same.  I've only used TY and Mam-A Gold CDRs since 1990s.  

However, I demagnetize both surfaces and the player drawer prior to use using a Walker Talisman (easier and quicker than the Acoustic Revive CD1 (now they're up to a CD3 version).  Demagnetizing makes a significant difference compared every time versus the difference between a first generation burned CDR and the original pressed disc. 

 Also, it is correct that multiple generation copies sound worse, probably due to R/W errors introduced into the copies.
I have a secret from Mr. Record.  Pressed commercial CDs can sound significantly different from one another, even if made at the same pressing plant.  We have found multiple copies that include hotter and less dynamic sound, warmer or cooler sound, thinner and richer sound.  Why, we can speculate that the manufacturing process does not create exact copies of the digital information on pressed discs perfectly. 

Sort of like vinyl pressing differences.  One can hear differences on the same stamper (so many analogophiles think that the hot stamper number is the end all of their search for the best stamper).depending on whether it is an early or late pressing from the same stamper (fresh versus nearly worn out stamper).  There are other variables as well.  

So, within the realm of pressed CDs, there exists differences from the same pressing plant.  The only way one can tell what is the hot or preferred CD is by listening to it.