Allthatbach54, the op referred this thread to another thread touting a response by, IMHO, an unreliable source. I didn't bring Mr. Collins into this thread, Mr. Stein did. However I did respond with my opinion, and it is just that, of the source. If Mr. Stein refers us to that as a model answer, it seems fair game to challenge the source, as well as the veracity of the information.
Now that we have cleared that up I find myself in agreement with grannyring that the OP is trolling. YMMV.