i would think Copper would be good. especially an alloy that is tougher (so it will not bend if dropped)
The problem of the tarnish could be overcome with plating or a coating. A highly polished (then coated) copper platter with a lead interior (more mass toward the outer rim)... Mmmm.
Or composite sandwiches. I guess it is money. Stuff like this costs a lot to make. Easier/cheaper to make a four inch thick acrylic than a one inch thick copper alloy.
The problem of the tarnish could be overcome with plating or a coating. A highly polished (then coated) copper platter with a lead interior (more mass toward the outer rim)... Mmmm.
Or composite sandwiches. I guess it is money. Stuff like this costs a lot to make. Easier/cheaper to make a four inch thick acrylic than a one inch thick copper alloy.