Are tiny subwoofers worthwhile?


I have several systems set up, in both medium sized and small rooms. I'm wondering about some of the really tiny subs like Velodyne MiniVee 8 or 10. In principle they should be perfect for a small room, but, I've noticed that generally smaller subs seem to sound a lot less relaxed than larger ones. Certainly they go less deep, but that might be good in a small room where a large sub might overpower it. I guess the breakthrough in size comes from a combination of using a high power class D amp and a smaller driver, but how well does this work in practice?

Do any of you have experience trying out latest generation of high quality VERY small subs in small rooms (e.g. 10 x 12).

Thanks,
Art
artmaltman
Check out Boston Accoustics PV1000. I thought it sounded pretty good in a demo.
In a small room with music fine. Big room big rig you need most of the time larger cones to push out greater amounts of air.
I use a Velodyne SPL800II in a small room with good results. To alleviate what I considered a sluggish output I moved the sub out into the room centered between and even with the speakers. The sub adds just the right amount of bottom, filling in room ambiance. This Velodyne is also easy to integrate, I imagine the newer model with remote control would be even easier.
Artmaltman,

I've had great success with the Velodyne SPLR 1000s (2 in the LR 2 channel / HT) and also the newer REL R series (3 in different systems).

Although a bit pricey, the RELs are simply fantastic with music and are very fast and mate well with just about any speaker and especially so with a quick single driver speaker. The Velos are no slouch either and, while they have different modes (Rock & Pop / Games / HT / Jazz), for music I always run them in Jazz mode. This keeps things nice and tight with no flab or exaggeration whatsoever.

Cheers,
Garry