Room matters


Hi team, I'd like to propose an intriguing question to the community.
What's the difference between Proac D28 and D38? Ovator S-600 and S-400? Neat MF5 and MF7? Avalon Ascendant and Indra? Gamut L5 and L7? Pioneer S1-EX and S3-EX?
The answer to all of the above questions is "none"!
It depends on the room size. Assuming to have a well balanced and top of the art electronic system, if someone wants to improve from a loudspeaker point of view there is no way in doing it unless with a bigger room, hence a bigger loudspeaker. (changing brand because of personal taste and budget is not to be cosidered).
Am I too much provocative?

Thanks for sharing your ideas.
wafer
Agreed - the room is the elephant in the room - possibly why many of the regular contributing experts here will not even share a few pix. Nevertheless there are differences in speakers that are significant too.
soooo, then room correction like the technology from Tact/Lyngdorf should be able to have a positive affect on most systems?
may want to add the music matters as well. I can easily make my system sound like about any adjective you care to mention by careful music selection. Not just Kb/s or mp3 vs. wav/flac either. been listening carefully to my new setup for 5 months and I'm just now getting to have a good understanding of the characteristics of it "on average". course I could be slow as I am a new hifi enthusiast.
One can use large loudspeakers in small rooms with very good results. Depends on the design. Some large speakers need space to intergate. Some dont.
In my experience, the Lyngdorf gear can dramatically improve how the room affects the sound.

I had never been able to get smooth bass response in any listening room. I have never had the luxury of a dedicated room – speaker placement and listening position have always had wife-based and room-sharing based constraints.

My new system is a Lyndorf TDA2200i, Focal BE1007s, Perraux 3150 amp and Lyngdorf W210 corner woofers. The TDA2200i has a crossover and time delay in the digital domain to integrate the two speaker systems. It also has a room correction module that claims to minimize room effects.

I am very, very happy with the result. Out-of-the-box, after the 30 minute setup process, I got bass flat to about 30Hz and really nice imaging.

However, like anything else audio, tweaking can yield major improvements.

After reading Jim Smith’s book “Get Better Sound,” I made several changes to the room (mostly WAF-friendly tricks for shared-use rooms). Then I ran through the Lyngdorf setup again. Huge, huge improvement. It’s as if the Lyngdorf can make certain improvements based on the starting point. So the better the starting point, the better the result…..

So, in my opinion, the room is no longer the limiting factor that it has been.