*****that we all like certain styles of jazz, that no one style is better than the other, and that the only consideration that is subject to intellectual analysis is the skill level of the performer; THAT is what determines what is good music or bad. ***
If this were true, we would all have thousands of CDs / LPs full of music we hated, or did not like, but bought because of the skill level of the performer. Just like right this minute, I am sure you can analyze Shepp and point out a hundred things he is doing correctly. To me it is just so much sound. Incoherent sound. Noise?
So YOU may think this is GOOD music. If you do, I can assure you , you are in a very tiny minority.
BTW, both are capable of playing good music, this just ain't it. Esp for Roach.
If this were true, we would all have thousands of CDs / LPs full of music we hated, or did not like, but bought because of the skill level of the performer. Just like right this minute, I am sure you can analyze Shepp and point out a hundred things he is doing correctly. To me it is just so much sound. Incoherent sound. Noise?
So YOU may think this is GOOD music. If you do, I can assure you , you are in a very tiny minority.
BTW, both are capable of playing good music, this just ain't it. Esp for Roach.