Tri-Planar Vll "SE Upgrade"

rfogel8, Thanks for your advice but I would also need to ''trade in''

40 of my MC carts, 30 MM carts and my Kuzma Stabi Reference

in order to satisfy your advice. You started this thread with your

question about Triplanar. My question is also about Triplanar.

Your statement: ''this thread sure got weird'' can only mean that

you don't like my question and the  possible implication. ''Possible''

because my statement is about my own sample and does as

such not imply that other samples also can't track more than 50

microns. But if this is also the case with other samples ???

Syntax is the only member who questioned Triplanar's construction

in the other Triplanar thread. According to him the problem with

Triplanar is its ''energy transfer''. Herb Papier was a watchmaker

and not a mechanical engineer. So it may be the case that he deed

not even thought about ''energy transfer'' as a relevant design

issue. That my Triplanar skips the groove by 60 microns may be

connected with this ''energy transfer'' but also may mean that

my sample is a single exception and that all other samples can

track 100 microns if the used cart also can.

That you don't like my contribution does not imply that my

question is irrelevant. Also the fact that most participants in

this thread don't own or don't use any test records says something

about them and not about the records themself. Every cart producer

use test records for at least the measuring of the output as well

the tracking capability of their carts. Interesting to know that our

amateur members know better.

brf, ''a problem which I feel does not exit''. Well existance is

not as easy as you think. The most physicist may have believed

that Higgs particle does exist but we in Europe spend huge

amount of money to prove that this particle realy exist. What you

feel is irrelevant for my question. You are entitled to say: ''I don't

care about your question'' but you are not entitled to state that

there is no tracking issue because you feel this way. What kind

of argument is this; ''oratio pro domo?''

 For such statement you would need to repeit my experiment and

if your result is different you can then say: the issue does not exist

because I checked with test records made for this purpose.

As I mentiond before Benz LP S claims  80 microns by VTF of

2 g. while Windfeld claim 100 microns by 2,6 g. Do you think that

such claims are based on feelings?