I have found it difficult to pick one due to the scarcity of the choices these days which led me to th LP8. This indecision caused me to drop the ball, but getting a replacement is still lurking around in the back of my mind.
I own the SE Engineering 879 bidirectional antenna that once replaced a directional Radio Shack that I had mounted on a rotor in the attic of my old home. The Radio Shack was terrific and provided strong clean signals. The SE Engineering is good, and that's what I'm living with today. When I moved to a new home, I left the Radio Shack in the attic. Stupid! So, I'm still scratching my head.
Kenny