I don't get it

Bander if you want user experience please tell us the speaker brand and model. Then with some input from others on YOUR speakers you might as your op states 'get it'.

I've seen this happen reasonably often in audio for speakers, preamps & power amps. A certain speaker manuf was wary of users trying anything other than the hard rubber (or was it plastic?) & very sturdy feet that were factory-fitted. The whole speaker system was designed as 1 holistic component which included the feet.
I also got a very similar response from a preamp manuf - he told me that his factory-fitted feet were the best & that he had taken care of vibration control in the chassis & overall product & that adding fancy-shmancy feet would do nothing to improve the sonics.
Same deal with an amp manuf who said that using metal feet would make the sound of his amps bright & that his factory-fitted feet (very sturdy) are the best.
Quite common for the manuf to say this but as I found out, they are not always right! Experiment & listen & you might find a better feet solution for your application.

You might try what I did in my last home. Check what is under your carpet. Is it cement, plywood, linoleum? I had old hard linoleum under my carpet. I have a tall set of Dunlavy SC3's. I went and bought 6 metal cones, three per speaker. I had 2 cones on each left and right rear corner, and one cone in the middle in the front edge. The sharp point of the cone penetrated the rug and coupled directly over the hard linoleum. One last thing; you will notice that with only one cone in front, that the speaker has wobble room because there is nothing supporting the front left and right portion of the speaker base. I ended up getting small pieces of cork, about 3 inches in diameter, and gently snuggled it in each front left and right corner. That made the speaker more stable. I think that you'll find the direct coupling of the speaker/cone tip/floor a good solution. It was for me. Good luck.

Thanks for the input and comments. The carpet is on an oak floor.I've decided to place 1 inch thick non resonant stone tile (perhaps granite) under the speakers and raise the speakers at all 4 corners with cones of some sort.

Here's my experience with the ESP Bodhran speakers. The speakers are supplied with spikes made of a plastic (perhaps Delrin) material with a brass pointed tip. I thought this might have been a cost saving measure to only make the tips brass. So, I ordered a set of solid brass Stillpoints.
Wow, what a difference! Unfortunately not for the better. Leading edges became way prominent and the sound lost its organic wholeness. The sound was now way Hi Fi, like a TV with the color and contrast controls set to high.
So, the manufacturers choice for the spike was well chosen based on actual listening and not a cheap out on material.
The speakers are on carpet over concrete slab.