2. speakers
  3. 142272-123707

Magico A3 vs S3 MKI

All

I have been a long time lurker and wanted to get some help with a decision. 

For the past 3 months I have been auditioning speakers in the 10k-15 range (both used and new) and have largely decided upon A3. 

Source gear
1. Hegel H360
2. Music played via Tidal

I had gone into A3 Audition as a skeptic and was expecting it to be clinical/ analytical. However I was surprised
1. It felt music and laid back (in a good way). Kind of speaker that I could listen to for hours and not get fatigued
2. Really liked the texture of the bass
3. Vocals made me feel I was right in the room

While I didn’t like some of the R&B music I played through them (eg Amy Winehouse), overall this met more of my needs than 10+ other speakers I have listened to. 

I wanted to check if anyone has had a chance to compare them to S3 MKI. I am getting a barely used S3 for almost the same price. However it might not be possible to do a fully controlled comparison of the two. So I wanted to get views from those who have listened to both. 

At at this stage not trying to broaden the search and simply trying to pick between these two. 
vinoacoustics
vinoacoustics OP
6 posts
 
@stereo5 you may be mixing A3 with something else. It’s $9800. Original S3 MKI was $22600

Also while Magico sound may have a signature, it has changed over time and become more neutral/ musical. One couldn’t call original Q3s neutral. 
shadorne's avatar
Ag insider logo xs@2x
shadorne
7,333 posts
 
If it doesn’t work with R&B then I would re-examine your choice or determine if it was the listening room or something else.

A good speaker should work equally brilliantly with absolutely anything - absolutely anything. A speaker that works with some kinds of music but not others is obviously coloured and or distorting.

The only thing that should differ between recordings or styles of music is how loud it needs to be played to sound its absolute best. Most recordings have a loudness sweet spot that was determined by the engineer and producer. This sweet spot is the volume level where the recording overall sounds best.
erik_squires
5,268 posts
 
Vino,

Where there seems to be the most disagreement about the Magico’s has to do with the lower voice and piano registers as well as the treble tilt.

I encourage you to listen for yourself, and make sure these areas are what you like.

Some have suggested these two areas are THE difference between the series.

I’m deliberately not making a recommendation. Buy what you like, but pay attention to these two areas if given a chance to audition, and try to audition at your actual listening levels.

Best,
E
stereo5's avatar
stereo5
2,766 posts
 
@vinoacoustics...…………..

oops, you are right.  I was thinking of the Q3, my bad.
sciencecop
79 posts
 
@shadorne
The only thing that should differ between recordings or styles of music is how loud it needs to be played to sound its absolute best.

So are you saying that there are no bad recordings??

Unfortunately, the better the speakers the more it will reveal recording flaws (Sadly, most of Amy Winehouse recording are awful). Doesn’t have anything to do with music type.
More to discover