Complete newbie needing guidance/purchase advice


Hi folks-

First of all, let me apologize in advance for a lengthy post. I'm a brand new forum member after recently being introduced to this site by an acquaintance who heard I was looking for sound advice... As my thread title states, I'm completely ignorant when it comes to the audiophile world, but I really want to start building a system and learn something in the process. A little background on me: I've been making a living as a recording artist and studio musician for almost 20 years, but my career choice as a music-maker has somehow ironically detached me from the simple pleasure of just sitting and _listening_ to music for the sheer enjoyment of it. My wife and I are currently in the process of remodeling our bonus room into a media room, and one of my objectives is to at the very least turn it into a space where I can do some critical listening.

I currently don't have anything decent... Just some old Bose bookshelf speakers and a Yamaha surround receiver. The closest thing to 'something decent' that I own are a pair of Etymotic ER-4S headphones coupled with a Headroom headphone amplifier.

The big limiting factor is my budget. Given that fact, maybe I have no business posting here... I will probably need to build this piece-by-piece over time, so I'm content with having to stretch the process out. I'm not concerned with having to have the 'best' of anything; I would just really like to make listening to music an engaging and emotional experience for me like it was for me many years ago.

Would a speaker purchase be a good place to start? I was perusing the Audiogon classifieds today and saw that there is actually a pair of DK Designs LSA-2's for sale local to me. The asking price is at the top of my speaker budget, a little over a grand, which I realize is probably 'chump change' in the audiophile world. However, I've read some reviews and they seem mostly positive. Would be super-convenient to be able to find something nice that was used and local, but as I said before, I'm completely new to this. Another related question: Is it better to go with floor-standing speakers, or can decent sound also be accomplished with bookshelf speakers combined with a subwoofer?

Also, what are the other 'basic' components that would need to be purchased? The only other thing I know I'd love to have would be a decent turntable; I'd love to be able to go and purchase some of my favorite classic albums to listen to once again. Do I need a separate preamp and power amp combination? Are there any 'receivers' that do a decent job of covering both tasks?

Any other feedback or direction you experts could throw my way would be greatly appreciated... Thanks in advance!
renaissanceman9
Hi Renaissanceman - since you seem to be a fan of classical music and possibly an old school guy, you might want to consider going an old school route here - horn speakers and tube electronics. As you probably know being an engineer, many of the great orchestral recordings of the so-called "golden age" were mastered using Altec A7's and MacIntosh amps.

That said, however you decide to set up your system, most definitely the speakers should be first. If you don't like the sound of your speakers, you won't like the sound of your system, period.
Renaissanceman,

Welcome to our world of craziness. I don't have as much experience with this stuff as a lot of others, but I was pretty much where you are about 10 years ago.

In looking at building a system, consider whether you want to focus on surround sound or music. I think your main focus is stereo rather than surround, but you say it's going to be an A/V room, so I'm not quite sure. This is what a great salesman told/asked me the first time I walked into a hifi shop looking for a system...

Are you sure you need surround sound? What do you watch. If you're like me and mainly watch sitcoms, comedies and March Madness, you might not miss surround sound as much as you think. A great 2 channel system (with or without a subwoofer) could sound a lot better than a surround system for equal money. Using round numbers, a $1k 2 channel integrated amp will sound better than a $1k AVR. 2 speakers for $1k will sound better than 5 or more speakers that total $1k. 2 speakers set up correctly can easily give you a front right, left, and center channel speaker effect. I know this first hand, as this is what I've been using.

But if you're into surround sound effects like bullets quizzing by your ears, 2 speakers aren't going to cut it. That's something you need to evaluate for yourself.

Some people will say to integrated a 2 channel system into your proposed surround system. This can be accomplished, but it's a bit of a hassle (using a 2 channel integrated amp and an AVR).

If going the 2 channel route, I'd recommend getting the best amplification you can afford. Some people recommend speakers first, some recommend source first. Neither of the 3 approaches are incorrect IMO. I recommend amplification first, as I feel that's the potentially longest term investment in a 2 channel system. Getting the most neutral amp that gets out of the way the most sonically will stay with you during upgrades/changes to everything else. Source formats come and go. IMO people change speakers for frequently than amplification.

A few years ago I bought a Bryston B60 integrated amp when I first started upgrading the system I bought in college. The B60 has stayed in my system through every change I've made. Every change I've made has had a definite sonic change, which tells me the B60 isn't holding the system back. Through owning it for the last few years, it's become quite apparent that it gets out of the way and let's the music flow. Not to mention that Bryston amplification has a 20 year transferrable warranty, and I think you can see why I'm recommending amplification first.

Don't skimp on the source! People have the mentality that digital is all 1s and 0s. It doesn't all sound the same to my ears. For a mix of movies and music, I'd recommend looking into a universal player, and getting an outboard DAC for CDs. That way you've got a great video player, and the music side is handled by a 2 channel hifi component. Or you could look into a streamer like a Sonos or Squeezebox and connect that to a DAC.

Speakers must be appropriate for the space they're in. Huge speakers in a small room can sound just as bad as small speakers in a huge room, albeit a different type of bad. Don't rule out monitors augmented by a sub or tower speakers. 19x13 doesn't sound like a room that's big or small, but the ceiling height, if it's open to other rooms (and if so how big is the opening and where) and what else is in the room will dictate which will probably work better.

The biggest thing in a system IMO is the room-speaker interface. How the speakers fit the room, where the speakers and listening chair are placed, and the room acoustics are far more important than the electronics IMO. I've heard great systems sound like crap in a bad/poorly set up room, and I've heard systems I thought would be mediocre at best sound fantastic in rooms that were optimized for the stereo.

Before getting into what gear to buy, I suggest getting a copy of Jim Smith's Get Better Sound book. It'll give you an idea of how things should be set up before you start bringing in stuff. You could even use some of his tips to maximize what you've currently got. It gets a bit obsessive compulsive, so don't get overwhelmed.

Lastly, I recommend finding a good dealer or several. Let them know your goals and that you're upgrading one piece at a time. Hear complete systems at your proposed budget, and above and below it. That way, you'll know what your budget will get you. Maybe spending a few dollars more will make a huge difference, or maybe you can get what you want for a bit less. Only one way to find out. Furthermore, if you hear complete systems, you'll know what the end result will sound like.

Seeking out local audiophiles and clubs is a great way to hear stuff too, so long as you're hearing stuff you can afford.

Just some thoughts. I didn't think the post would be this long.
its great to get all the advice from people who have taken the journey on this hobby but practically its you who has to decide what kind of sound you would prefer every component has its pros and cons that doesn't mean the equipment is bad its just that the flavor you are looking at is the one only you can select so listening extensively and trusting your ears is very important resulting in listening music or facing the music of selling the gear
Renaissanceman9,
Moniors are stand-mounted speakers requiring the use of sturdy stands.
I think you are ok using your XBOX for now.
How much do you want to spend on an amp? Did you give your total budget for the entire system.?
Although it is awesome to go out to Audio dealers to listen to different systems, it is frowned upon to do this, find what you love, and buy it used here. That said, many people do this.
I have bought all of my gear here sight and sound unseen, and I have been super happy with every single puchase.
If you just do your research and ask questions and opinions,your good to go!!
Lastly, are you willing to stretch your speaker budget a bit. (say $1300)
Todd
Getting into audio is great fun but can be very frustrating at times. You will make your share of mistakes; we all do. I don't like just telling people what they should go out and buy regarding equipment because it can bias you in a certain way and/or be just bad advice given what you like now and what you will come to like once you gain more knowledge. Looking back on all of the mistakes I have made over the years, to get where I am now and have a good sounding system, I can give you some tips as not to make some of the mistakes that I made. Below are a few things that I wish someone had told me.

1. Stop reading equipment reviews. (I know you are going to ask why but there is no one simple answer. I could write a book on the subject.)

2. Never, ever try to fix problems with tubes and/or cables. You will fail. It is much easier to just fix the system. (I am not saying that tubes and cables are not important or don't make a difference. They are valid purchases, just not band aids.)

3. Don't use your ears. (Use your head. Your ears are on your head so they can be used along with some good judgment.)

4. You will always hear people arguing about what is more important component: Speakers or the Source. The answer is the preamp. (The truth is every component is important. One bad or mismatched component messes up the whole system. I say the preamp because it is at least as important as any component and most of the systems that I see fail is because the preamp is overlooked in some way.

5. Don't set prices before buying equipment. If, for example, you allow yourself $5000 for a new CD player, you will end up getting one for $5000. Find one you like first, and then worry about the price. There is a good chance you might find one you like for less. If you like something for more, you will be selling you $5000 player the minute you hear the one you want.

Good luck with your purchases. I hope some of this info can help you out.