Benchmark dac - why such diverging opinions?


I'm puzzled.
Audiophile sites and magazines continue to rave about the benchmark dac (HDR, USB, pre,...). Perfect rendition, studio quality, unbeatable value,...

Yet criticism stacks up high on many blogs. Too harsh, not musical enough,...

Why such divergence? Does its popularity make it the one one loves to hate? Are magazines just biased in their reviews? Are audiophile bloggers not good judges of quality. Are those considering buying a dac at that price having sub-par components whose imperfections the benchmark dac amplifies, while those going higher end don't consider the dac adequate vs a berkeley or weiss? Where is the catch?

I ended up buying a w4s dac. I considered the benchmark yet never had the chance to audition it.
mizuno
"Musical" is just another way of saying "I like it", isn't it? Even "it sounds like live music" is totally subjective; everyone takes away something different from the experience of live music.

One thing that's only been touched on briefly so far that may effect opinions about the Benchmark is that it is "pro" gear. I don't think this effected my own opinion; I respect the hard-nosed engineering ethic of much pro gear. But some people crinkle their nose at gear from any company with a pro reputation.

By the way, I did try the DAC1 with the different output level settings (a feature I wish more gear had).
Did you prefer the higher or lower gain settings? Any reason for higher than 2v for amps with 1v sensitivity?
Interesting thing about pro gear - it's not only used by musicians but also to record and process a very high percentage of all music released.

Many audiophiles are still in search of tone controls (preconfigured to their taste) as long as they don't have to admit that's what they're really after.
Guys, It's designed for pro audio so it needs careful adjustments to sound good in home HiFi!! look at my thread at:
http://forum.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/fr.pl?ddgtl&1292529269&read&keyw&zzbenchmark

And learn how to get the best out of the DAC-1, if you use the DAC-1 straight out of the box, it does sound a little sterile, but if you use it properly, the sound is neutral and balanced! Not warm but not sterile either.

A mellow-sounding DAC is always easier to please, but use your common sense here: if a DAC can win numerous awards including both Stereophile and The Absolute Sound, it has to have more merits than shortcomings! It's designed for pro audio so it needs careful adjustments to sound good in home HiFi!!
Yingtonggao - I found most vivid and detailed sound at 0dB jumper position. It is the same finding as in the following review:

http://www.positive-feedback.com/Issue26/benchmark_dac1.htm

I use volume control directly driving power amp from XLR outputs but according to Benchmark signal path with or without volume control is identical. The only issue, I suspect, might be quality of the volume pot itself.