2. speakers
  3. 1101238970

Quad 989s--personal experience and opinions?

I'm seriously considering the 989s for my 2-channel-audio/multichannel-audio/home-theater system (for the fronts only). Currently I'm running 4 Kindel PLS-As, a design from the late '80s that are tall, sensitive (94dB), and definitely full range. They're driven by a c-j Premier Eleven-A (70wpc, tubed). I've owned planar speakers in decades past, both electrostatics and magnetics, and loved the spaciousness and especially depth of sounstage they produce. I've listened briefly to the 989s and will lots more before I commit to them, but I'd love to hear from A'gonists with personal experience with them, both good and bad. Generally, I’m an unabashed Romantic, loving the big-orchestra classical and film music from 19th and later centuries--and Diana Krall and the old Dave Brubeck Quartet, among others, too. My room is c. 21' wide, 19' deep, and 6-1/2 to 12' high, with few parallel surfaces.

I've read many reviews* of them. If I understand what I'm reading, the 989's deviations from perfection probably include: 1. Bass not extending all the way into the bottom of the bottom octave--which, of course, includes merely 99% of the speakers out there; 2. Inability to play as loudly as some want them to, altho a couple reviewers said their ears gave up before the speakers did; 3. Fussiness about setup, which, of course, makes them similar to all bipolar radiators; and 4. Slight beaminess of treble. Its skills are many and I won’t go into my impressions.

So...owners...what do you love and not love about them? Cautions for me?

* the most curious being a comment from a fellow in one of those consumer-review sites who 3 times said they had too much bass!
.
128x128jeffreybehr
nrchy's avatar
nrchy
2,111 posts
 
Jeffery
The reviewer you mentioned must be a buffoon who knows nothing about speaker setup. He's probably had every speaker he ever listened to, in the exact same spot.

I have heard these speakers, but only in a HiFi shop. I was impressed with them. For the gear, and music you mentioned, I would think these would be a very good match. The only problem I can fore see is, they have too much bass : )
px25
31 posts
 
Jeffrey, we are currently audiotioning a pair of Quad 989s in the store I work at and they are awesome. In terms of tonal balance, transparency, transient response, and midrange, these speakers are on par with the best available. Bass is actually quite good, in fact much better than I was expecting. Set up properly, you should get usable output into the mid thirties. The lowest octive is missing, but what is present is extremely good in terms of tonality and non-box colorations. Dipoles do low bass, but do not have nearly as much output in the lower octaves as conventional dynamic speakers. They are not the loudest or most dynamic speakers, but they have performed well with Tool, the Stones, and a few other kinds of music we thought they would fall apart on. All in all, they are spectacular speakers, the kind that will make you forget about gear and motivate you to buy more software instead. From everything you have described, these speakers should work well for you.
a_thomas
9 posts
 
I own a pair. They have astonishing clarity. You seem to know that they don't play loud, but people have different ideas of what is loud for them - I'll leave you to judge.

My room is 20x14x8 with a large coupled room which makes it about the size of yours. I was quite happy with how loud the 989's played.

For the bottom octave, you should look at a sub. Without wishing to stir up a hornets nest, you should consider doing bass management and steer low frequencies away from the quads. This is best done digitally.

As for placement, they need space, but they are not nearly as fussy as some folks like to make out.

I'd suggest you consider some more powerful (solid-state) amplification too - I used Bryston PowerPaks.

I've tried all kinds of music. Good speakers are good speakers and the notion that some speakers are good for only some kinds of music is nonsense. Rock music sounds fantastic on quads, you'll only be limited to how loud you can play..

They do "beam" and have a sweet spot. This might be an issue if you are trying to fill a room for other listeners. They are not a "party" speaker.

Finally, these are big speakers, which dominate a room. Make sure that they are acceptable to your family. Home demo is advisable if you can swing it with your dealer.
More to discover