2. speakers
  3. 1107439546

Is the dunlavy SC-IV still worth to buy?

Hi,
I just sold my Nautilus 805, and looking for an replacement upgrade. I looking for used speakers in the range of $1500-$2500. Since I live in Indonesia, I have little option in such speakers: Vandersteen 2Ce Sig ($1200), Michael Green Chameleon ($1900), Spendor LS3/5a ($1100), and Dunlavy SC-IV ($2400). I understand that each speaker has its own strength and weakness, but I found that Vandy2ceSig and Dunlavy SC-IV have such a great review. I've tried the Spendor LS3/5a, and quite impress with it, but I think that it would be better to get a floorstanding speaker, thus I don't have to get a sub-woofer right away. Regarding Michael Green Chameleon, I could not find much review on it, so my final tought would be Dunlavy SC-IV (not the new SC-IVa version). Thus, I would like to get some recommendation whether it's still woth it to get it. Or should I just get the Spendor LS3/5a, which many people say it has an impressive vocal?
My system:
Krell KSA250
Krell KSP-7B pre
AudioNote DAC-2 (not the latest version)
Jadis JD-3 CD
Not too high-end cables interconnect and speakers.
(my system mostly old since I have a very limited budget)
Any recommendation would be really appreciated. Thanks. (Sorry for my bad english)
atjandra888
atjandra888 OP
18 posts
 
Thanks so much for all the replies/ infos. One thing I forgot to mention is that my room is only about 3 x 3 meters (probably about 10' x 10'). I understand that according to some people, it would be too small. Then the questions is; is it still ok to get SC-IV, knowing that the spreakers placement would not be as recommended? My alternative then is to put them on my living room, which is big but not private (and not air-conditioned, thus not to good for the Krell amp..). Thanks again.
rcprince
2,830 posts
 
That's really too small a room for the IVs; you need to sit a good deal away from them to get the drivers to integrate properly, and I think the extended bass, particularly with that small a room and its square shape causing room nodes, will be too much. You're better off with small speakers like the Spendors, maybe the Vandersteens or a smaller Dunlavy model, or perhaps even small monitors with a sub.
sean
6,229 posts
 
Rcprince is right on the money. Monitors with a low Q sealed sub would work best here. You're already going to have problems in terms of bass response due to the size and shape of the room, so you don't want a woofer system that lacks control and has a big output peak at resonance to deal with. Big speakers and / or smaller speakers with drivers that are widely spaced apart work best in larger rooms. Sean
>

PS... Your "budget challenged" system is quite impressive and there is NO need to apologize for your English.
praudio
39 posts
 
For your small room Dunlavy III is better choice.
More to discover