I still wouldn't cut the Vandy's. My Treo's are great, but having the EQ bass would be the way to go without adding too much to the size of the speaker. I urge you to at least give them a listen. Bob |
I am a little late to this thread. But, knowing ctsooner (I own his old Treo's). I have to say, that they will not 'overwhelm' you listening area. Period. To add to your confusion, let me add that I also have an office (10x10x8) and am using the Vandy VLR's with a pair of HSU subs. I have to say it plays very nicely. I have the speakers mounted near the ceiling and directed toward my desk-so nearfield listening. Non fatiguing, and very engaging. I wouldn't call it the best setup, but for work it certainly is more than most. My Treo/2wq setup resides in my LR/DR (12x18x8-speakers near the middle-9', and about 2 feet from the walls). Actually, it is a bit more complex than that, but you'd need a picture. Suffice it to say, they aren't in the 'best' of spots. To my ears, the Treo's sound as natural and unassuming as a speaker can be. I hate to be confined to a single area when I listen. In fact, my main seat is almost directly in front of the left speaker. I don't hear that speaker beaming directly at me, but a full sound stage. An imaginary hall that emanates between/behind the speakers. I can sing praises for these speakers for a long time, but the choice is yours. If you like, I can give you more details, rather than hijack a thread. Bob
|
@tomic601 , I broached this with John Rutan and he seemed to poo poo the idea of digital room correction. I am intrigued by it, as Almarg seems to find his DEQX to be a valuable addition. Are you using it with your systems? B |
@yyzsantabarbara , Funny, I thought I read you were discounting them, but I can't find the post. Bob |
If you want something stand mounted the Vandy VLR is exceptional for the money. I have them in my office, using them off axis (actually mounted near the ceiling corners on wall mounts). Very nice and relaxing, and detailed. I have listened to them with and without subs, when placed by corners, the bass is substantial. Bob |
I will still stand by my recommendation of the Vandy VLR. Of course, it isn't up to the Treo's, but I have to say it really makes my office alive. I didn't think they were up to the task, and I tried a pair of Zu Omen Bookshelves, but the Vandy VLR beat them hands down. You can now get them with the Carbon Tweeters, though at a higher cost.
Bob |
Ooohh, I hate it when my post gets lost after all my typing... B |
@yyzsantabarbara . I have never heard of the Kaya until now. Thanks for posting that, now I have something else to try listening to in addition to MBL and German Physics. Bob |
@yyzsantabarbara . If you do get the Treo's, I don't think you will be 'frustrated' by their performance in your office. The best part is when they can be moved to the larger room, you can get the Vandy subs and be as close to a Quatro at a fraction of the cost(buying used, that is). Bob |
@yyzsantabarbara , The whole DSP/DEQX stuff seems to me a bit much. Though I can understand the concept, I just don't see why you have to go through hoops to get 'perfect' sound. Just my opinion... I also wonder why, considering that you can tailor the sound to the room, that you can't take any speaker and tune it to the sound you like? Like make a Magico sound like a Persona, or at least closer? Bob |
|
@yyzsantabarbara , Yes, thanks for clarifying things. I know that everyone's room isn't the 'perfect' room by a long shot, but I think a good speaker manufacturer takes this into consideration and produces a product that should sound good in as many rooms as possible. Hence, my love of the Vandy's. DSP and all the other stuff is icing on the cake. IMHO.
B |
|
You get around Tomic
Though I prefer Papaya King. Hey, I'm a NY boy... B |
I know almarg uses the DeQX and loves it. You should PM him. Bob |
Saw new pics and left a post. I'm glad you are getting closer to what you want. B |
What SQ differences between the Treo's and the Kaya's did you notice. Bob |