Do you ...Center Channel?


Hello,

To me it is difficult to set a center speaker in the living room. Underneath the TV would be too low. On top of the TV (LCD) would be unpractical because in may case the center channel would be fairly big and heavy.

I imagine that most of you, living in homes with a dedicated room, you have no issue. How about all the others like me, with limited space, would you have the center channel at all and go with a four speakers setup and set the preamp to 'No Center'? Or would you compromise in some other ways?
Thanks.

Regards,
baam23f
Markphd, I find your answer simplistic since the inventors of stereo (which means solid) found that it required a minimum of three channels across the front but, due to the technical limitations of the media of the time, only two were used in the commercial applications. There is a need for a good center channel, even if one sits in the "sweet spot," because the center signal information limits the spatial resolution to the sides.

This is not to say that 2channel stereo cannot be impressive and satisfying.

Kal
05-29-07: Slikric3000 wrote: "Nope I dont have a center ear. 1 speaker for each ear is all I can handle."

I miss your smiley. Otherwise, this is a common and silly idea.

Kal
OTOH, creating a phantom center when there is a discrete center signal creates inevitable phase/time errors in the process. This is noticeable even on-axis but mostly with music sources.

Really? How?
Of course you have to be sitting in the sweet spot and you must not be using a discrete mutichannel source

Most DSP's handle even discrete data and will allocate the information to the speakers as necessary.

Obviously if you don't have a DSP and you are competely missing Center information then it will sound terrible. The same applies if you have a 0.1 channel and are not using a sub or do not have the ability to program the DSP to send 0.1 channel to your main speakers.

Missing channels DO need to be added back in to whatever you have in terms of speakers in order to mantain balance of the sound field (this is important if you have LESS speakers than discrete channels and is another reason why surround gest a bad rap from stereo people, as they don't do it justice by making sure they are using ALL the available information)
My system consist of 4 full range speakers. The problem with the center that I am considering (Vienna Acoustics Oratorio) is that it's shape is not the conventional rectangular box but the front side is angled toward the top so that the speaker can be positioned on the bottom of the tv without the need to angle the speaker toward the top. But that positioning would be too low according to what has been said around. The front speakers are 52" tall. And the center would sit well below. My impression is that the oratorio was designed with the HT in mind more then the MC music. So far I am listening multichannel music with four speakers.