ATC SCM100 Anniversary?



Has anyone had any experience with the ATC SCM100 Anniversary?
I have MBL 6010D and Wadia 581i Se.
Any thoughts?
tomer_tsin

Shadorne,

I'm afraid a little from the midrange driver.
Dont you find it radiate to much sound presure?

Thanks,

Tomer
I have some reduced experience with active ATC speakers (ATCSCM-50 ASL ). Although I did not like their own matching preamp, when used with a top preamplifier such as ARC ref3 they sounded very good and represented good value for money in Europe.
Proac, a speaker brand I like very much, used the ATC medium dome unit in the top models – I still own a pair of response 5 in my attic AV system. Currently uses these medium units are used only the impressive D100 speakers. Unhappily I can not even imagine how Proac’s sound with MBL electronics.
Dont you find it radiate to much sound presure?

No. I find it is quite flat. But I understand why you might think so - many people do. And if you do then I think ATC is the wrong choice for you.

Basically it is not your more typical "scooped midrange" sound - so relatively speaking flat sounds "forward" compared to the norm these days (which is for an impressive bass with a dip in the midrange).

Speaker manufacturers well know that bass and treble sells (they have had fifty years to discover this)...so a scooped midrange has become the norm in order to meet customer preferences (and win in a shop floor demo). This also just happens to be the way the most common form of speaker on the planet nearly always will sound - I am referring to a two way with a woofer and a small tweeter (pretty common I think you will agree). Anyway, beaming on the large woofer causes an off axis dip in the upper mids. This sound is so prevalent as to have become what many people regard as the norm. It may be part of the reason why some complain that reproduced music never sounds real - I believe that somehow we can tell if the on axis and off axis response reaching our ears is not the same...we sense something not natural about the sound field (even if it is beautiful sounding)...it might be why MBL speakers are so impressive: they generate a fully balanced or convincing sound field.

Anyway - a technical explanation for what people like or don't like will not change the fact that the ATC midrange may well be much too forward relative to your preferences. In which case, a PMC three way might be a better choice for you - another good speaker of very similar design but more bass and a tad less midrange.

Shadorne,

I don't have any prejudice about the midrange driver, I will listen to the SCM 50ASL next week.

Thanks,

Tomer

What are the differences between the ATC SCM100 Anniversary and the ATC SCM100SL AT?

Is it only aesthetics/veneer?

Thanks,

Tomer
More to discover