Harbeth HL5 vs Magnepan 1.6qr Who wins??


Here's one I don't think has been asked. Which speaker is the best overall performer?
develyn50
Maggies, I just like them better. But I do like the Harbeths a lot. I think they are expensive but very good. I actually liked the Paradigm Signatures at a dealer, compared to the Harbeth's at about 2/5 the price.
Develyn50, have you heard either? How did you come to these two for comparison?
I own the Magnepan's and have been interested in the Harbeth's. I have not heard them as I have no dealer close by.
Fin1bxn,

Higher price doesn't always mean better speakers. I think Magnepan's aren't $5,000 because they don't have the expense of the cabinets. If Maggies came in high quality wood cabinets they just might cost $5,000.
I moved from Maggie 1.6 to Reynaud Trente and preferred the Reynaud's. I did not miss the open quality the Maggie has as much as some think you will (though that is a very nice thing about the Maggie speaker).

The bottom line for me is the Maggie needs lots of room and very good amplifiers to sound their best so part of my decision was based on these factors.