Jazz, that was a very thoughtful post, and I concur with it 100%. Not even the very best jazz musicians agreed on what is, or is not jazz; who is some "johnny come lately" to tell us what is, or is not jazz? There has been, and there always will be disagreement on the answer to that question; however, when one person has too much influence over the answer, it even affects the music.
Rok, you were so right; every Thread needs an OP to discern the intentions and meaning of a thread; by allowing too much latitude, "I" let this thread get out of hand. As long as it stayed within "logical" parameters, it bounced along just fine, even with disagreements.
I think we all have enough sense to know what is, and what is not "out of bounds"; how ever if any "Aficionado" doesn't know, I will be on him like stink on s--t,
Enjoy the music.

