1. Home
  2. speakers
  3. 127396-6918

Heat/Efficency of Speakers

What % of power sent to the speakers is turned to waste heat? That's the short version of my question.

I'm looking to minimize waste heat accross my stereo as my listening room is unforgiving come summer; no cooling and a computer system which cannot be relocated. I understand amplifier efficency & the classes as well as speaker efficency measured as W/db however the interplay eludes me.

Taking two hypothetical amplifiers: a Class A amplifier outputting 10W w/ 100W from the wall & a Class D outputting 200 w/ 220W draw I understand the D will be the cooler operator however this is where the discussion tends to end, D only wasting 20W vs the A amplifier's 90W. Considering appropriate speaker matches to each amp(as well as a standard HE speaker at say 95db/w), how do I determine the wattage converted sound and the watts spent as heat?

I'm asking because I was previously running a 10W tube amplifier in this room(4xel84 tubes) with 96db speakers. This was bearable in two hour doses this last summer. My friend assures me any Class D amplifier and many AB amps would have no such heating problems and says it's class not wattage that is my issue. Before I move to a different amplifier technology(and swap speakers, these voiced for SE tube partnering) I want to understand this issue fully. I'm unconcerned with power usage and only care about the heat.
redfuneral
almarg's avatar
almarg
8,673 posts
 
Redfuneral 12-12-2016
... my former SE Parallel EL84.
OK, then my previous supposition that the amp was biased in class AB was not correct, as a SE parallel amp will operate in class A.  So the 60 to 75 watt estimate I stated for the power consumption of the amp under typical listening conditions was probably somewhat low.

Regards,
-- Al
 

onhwy61's avatar
onhwy61
4,163 posts
 
Why don't you take a look at cooling vest/jackets.  They can be active or passive and are designed to keep your body core cooler than the surrounding environment.
brownsfan
1,238 posts
 
Al, thanks.  All of the caveats you listed I assumed would be understood so I did not explicitly state them.  Of course, the 2nd law demands that heat moves from an area of higher temperature to one of lower temperature.  If the listener is in a poorly insulated room, and the exterior is 40 degrees lower, and he opens the window, then the "disappearance" would be significant.   I also made an assumption that everyone participating in this discussion knows that less efficient speakers draw more energy into the room in order to afford a given dB level, and that energy ends up as heat. 
shadorne's avatar
shadorne
7,333 posts
 
@cleeds

You are correct in your statements but you have twice misquoted me. You correct me but my statements more or less agree with yours just that I have stated things a little differently.

if I say a speaker churns out between 99% and 90% as heat then that equates to an efficiency of 1% to 10% in sound energy.

1% it typical for a high efficiency near full range speaker as you stated - it loses 99% of energy as heat (hot voice coils). 10% efficiency would represent the upper limit for a horn speaker - it loses 90% of energy as heat.


cleeds
2,065 posts
 
shadorne
... if I say a speaker churns out between 99% and 90% as heat then that equates to an efficiency of 1% to 10% in sound energy ...
Quite so. But I don't think you can cite a loudspeaker system with 130 dB sensitivity, which is what would be needed to have a 99 percent efficient speaker.
 
More to discover