KT-88 vs. EL34


Hi. I have a modified Jolida 502 amp (not my main amp) currently using KT-88s and formerly the similar 6550s. Some have suggested that this unit will sound even better, power hit aside, modifying to accept EL-34s. The mod is easy. Anyone find this to be true or is it just another myth? Thanks in advance, Andy8400.

andy8400
I wouldn't say better, its more like different. 6550's and KT88 have a more "modern" sound to them. Highs are more extended, and bass has more definition. EL34's tend to focus more on the midrange. Keep in mind that I'm talking in general terms here. There's always exceptions.

If the amp was modified, do you know if its wired in triode? It makes a nice difference. 

Roger Modjeski of Music Reference and RAM Tube Works had for quite a while a forum on AudioCircle. On it he discussed tube amplifier design, tubes themselves, and the relationship between tube circuits and the performance characteristics of specific tube types---how the two are interrelated. The Music Reference Forum is no longer active (Roger has moved his business from Santa Barbara in Southern California to the Berkeley/Oakland area in Northern California, where he designs and builds amps, an ESL loudspeaker, and a subwoofer. He also teaches a course in amplifier design.), but remains readable on the AC site.

There is a LOT of information about tube circuits and tubes on the old Audiocircle MR Forum, well worth your time to peruse. Roger invented computer tube testing and matching, and is the world’s foremost authority on vacuum tubes. He’s not easy to reach by phone, but if you do you may be able to get a lot of your questions answered straight from the horses mouth.

I will say I personally very much dislike the 6550 tube from past experiences. I am a bit EL34 fan and find a nice balance in that tube of SET-esque richness and modern linearity. Particularly for me the Gold Lion KT77 variant has been a tremendous find and is my power tube of choice for my EL34 amp. Also I agree with sfall above circuit matters a lot my amp is triode wired and class A which is why I find it so rewarding.
Hi Andy -

I would make the case that this is very speaker dependent.  As you may be getting from the other posts, the sound is different as opposed to necessarily better or worse.

Are you still using the AR 4s?  For the longest time, I had the AR 302s as my speaker (latter day AR 5s).  When I used KT88s and 6550s, the sound was more fleshed out, with more force.  The EL34 sound was more delicate & balanced & intimate sounding.  The KT77s and 6CA7s seemed to get the best sound for me.  My amp was (still is) a Prima Luna PL5  

Rich