Pokey--don't know what "specs" you are talking about. That was solely based on listening.
Anyway, class D is all over the place, probably in the TVs, the music at the local bar, some powered speakers, etc.
I don't notice the odd effect in the class D amp in my sub. Seems to work just fine, there. Like after a kid touches a hot stove, just avoided them for consideration as a primary amp, for the past decade. A lot of folks really liked them, then, too.
Just seemed to me that there's a harder line between class-d lovers and haters than with some other products. So, that and my ten-year-old story led to what I thought was a legit question. Whether there is something about class-D or some sonic effect that some folks can hear and others can't, whether knowingly or not, beyond just good or bad hearing. Like--DLP TV, asparagus pee, tongue rolling, soapy cilantro, etc. Most people thought I was trippin' out with the DLP thing, and I suspect some folks who like class-d think the folks who sense this effect are nuts, too.
Love tubes, but, damn, they are killing me in the small rooms when it's 108 degrees out, and the AC vent can't keep up. Might be time to give a serious listen to some newer class d. If this "effect" has been remedied, or if I was just imagining it all, maybe a summer amp?
Interesting and informative thread.