Hmmmm.... A few thoughts reading this thread.
First, bo1972 sounds like a world class weenie.
Second, Wilson has no obsession with cloth domes and paper cone. They've used plenty of Focal W cones and various aluminum and titanium domes.
Third, I don't particularly care for B&W midrange. I think they sound sterile.
Forth, AMT's are nice transducers, especially the big dipoles, but they have their unique placement and implementation challenges you either like or don't. I think they're harder to do right than other drivers.
And fifth, I don't take a typical amateur listener's opinion very seriously. I begin to take a listener's opinion seriously when they've produced an extensive body of opinions, including products I'm familiar with, that gives me a tangible feel for what their experiencing. I've seen too many pictures of people's listening rooms to believe an amateur's opinion means anything. I can take all my room treatments down and stuff my Focals against the wall and they will sound shallow and harsh. I can place them along another wall and they will sound shouty and lack any bass. I'm not convinced too many put enough consideration towards placement and treatment to make their opinions worth a whole lot.
First, bo1972 sounds like a world class weenie.
Second, Wilson has no obsession with cloth domes and paper cone. They've used plenty of Focal W cones and various aluminum and titanium domes.
Third, I don't particularly care for B&W midrange. I think they sound sterile.
Forth, AMT's are nice transducers, especially the big dipoles, but they have their unique placement and implementation challenges you either like or don't. I think they're harder to do right than other drivers.
And fifth, I don't take a typical amateur listener's opinion very seriously. I begin to take a listener's opinion seriously when they've produced an extensive body of opinions, including products I'm familiar with, that gives me a tangible feel for what their experiencing. I've seen too many pictures of people's listening rooms to believe an amateur's opinion means anything. I can take all my room treatments down and stuff my Focals against the wall and they will sound shallow and harsh. I can place them along another wall and they will sound shouty and lack any bass. I'm not convinced too many put enough consideration towards placement and treatment to make their opinions worth a whole lot.

