Mr. Paul. I have an ancient Sony strd1011s in the closet that kind of does what you suggest a perfect amp does. There's a bunch of goofy low-fi surround/reverb effects that allows one to approximate what different seating positions and distances in various venues would sound like. That thing is cool to play around with, but it is far from perfect.
I might agree that a "perfect" amp would sound like no amp, but I completely disagree that a "perfect" amp would allow a volume knob to function as a zoom for proximity. That wouldn't be "perfect" to me, except perhaps from a point source in a true anechoic chamber. Cues for distance include much more than just volume. If the amp included those cues, it would no longer sound like "no amplifier."Â