Is it possible the P5 is the problem? Not because he plugged the amp into the P5. I doubt is any Pass amp would liked being plugged into a power conditioner.
When the OP is using the P5 for the front equipment could the P5, because of some internal problem, be causing the sound problem?
I didn't read any OP responses where he tried removing the P5 from the chain. I would try that. Even so far as unplugging the P5 from the AC mains outlet.
@proacman,
When the kitchen was remodeled did the electrician add any new circuits from the electrical panel to the kitchen? If yes he might have moved existing branch circuit wiring around inside the electrical panel, just physically moving wires with his hands when installing the new branch circuit wiring inside the electrical panel enclosure. Just the side to side moving of solid core branch circuit conductors around inside of an electrical panel can change the wire to branch circuit breaker terminal tightness connection.

