2. analog
  3. 133100-67598

Soundsmith Aida vs Hana sh

I would like some help in choosing the right cartridge for my set-up. I have a recently rebuilt sota sapphire series 3 with a pro-ject 10cc, Soundsmith Carmen-H into a Manley chinook se.
I really have these two in mind.

Soundsmith Aida & Hana sh

I’m looking for technical help on this, not opinions on what you think sounds better. I have heard both on different systems that were set-up for them and like both very much.The Hana being the winner for value and the Aida sounding the way a $2,000.00 cartridge should. The Hana maybe a little light at 5 grams for the stock counter weight on the 10cc & both seem to me to be a good match with the Manley.Please let me know what you think. Thank you
128x128pipetowers
everstar's avatar
everstar
6 posts
 
Never heard a Hana. 

I own the Aida. Aida had a lot more body then cheaper MC carts I have heard. It will have a wider soundstage, a little detail but yet remain very smooth and musical. Very natural/neutral sound. 

MC I have have heard in that 500/1200 range have been more analytical, less body and less musical. They might have a little sharper highs and a bit more "air". 

Don't underestimate the value of re-tipping. 
tzh21y
1,377 posts
 
everstar

MC I have have heard in that 500/1200 range have been more analytical, less body and less musical. They might have a little sharper highs and a bit more "air".

I have heard of nightmare scenarios with retips.  that odes not mean that retipping is bad.  Benz is retipping again.  get an old Glider and be happy.  Now thats a lot of cartridge for the money.  Better yet, get a ruby and be set for life. 
lewm
6,770 posts
 
Just to give a differing view, I owned an original Glider and then the next upgrade of the Glider, whatever it was called.  The Glider did not do anything glaringly wrong in my system but goose bumps were absent.  Then I tried another even more expensive HOMC and got the same or a very similar blah result. This was my bumpy road to not liking HOMC cartridges, at least compared to LOMC and MM/MI.
tzh21y
1,377 posts
 
lewn, I agree with you, but the glider is probably closer to the LOMC than many cartridges.  If one can swing the better LOMC carts, all the more power to them. 
analogluvr
800 posts
 
 I would second Lewm's notion.  I also tried a glider hi output and it left me cold. From my understanding you lose the benefits of MC when you go with a high output MC.  The chinook will support a low output cartridge, will it not?   Even if it didn't my next move would be to buy and a SUT and go for low output cartridges. Or go with MI. 
More to discover