@geoffkait
You make no sense. What you're saying here and up above makes no sense. What's more, you can't come close to proving it this or that was mastered in one polarity or another. The polarity of the fundamentals make no difference whatsoever. The problem of polarity lies in the the overtones and distortions generated by the instrument and the recording space. If you don't have those in proper phase/polarity, it completely changes the sound and it's pretty freaking obvious to even a sophomoric listener, much less an engineer who does this stuff for a living. If you're listening to stuff recorded and mastered by engineers that can't hear the difference between polarities and phases, you're listening to some real garbage. The polarity and phase of the spacial and distortion information goes a long way in defining the presence of the sound. Generally, positive polarity even order distortion gives the sound a crisp, clear, forward pop while negative phase distortion extends the depth of the sound field and presents more smoothly. That's the going theory on why odd order harmonics really stick out. They add a stiffness to the peaks of waveforms that sounds inorganic, because it is.
I'm certainly no SET lover myself, but at least I know why people like them. And unlike you, I've sat around and listened carefully to positive and negative polarity distortion and I'm very aware of what it's characteristics sound like.
You make no sense. What you're saying here and up above makes no sense. What's more, you can't come close to proving it this or that was mastered in one polarity or another. The polarity of the fundamentals make no difference whatsoever. The problem of polarity lies in the the overtones and distortions generated by the instrument and the recording space. If you don't have those in proper phase/polarity, it completely changes the sound and it's pretty freaking obvious to even a sophomoric listener, much less an engineer who does this stuff for a living. If you're listening to stuff recorded and mastered by engineers that can't hear the difference between polarities and phases, you're listening to some real garbage. The polarity and phase of the spacial and distortion information goes a long way in defining the presence of the sound. Generally, positive polarity even order distortion gives the sound a crisp, clear, forward pop while negative phase distortion extends the depth of the sound field and presents more smoothly. That's the going theory on why odd order harmonics really stick out. They add a stiffness to the peaks of waveforms that sounds inorganic, because it is.
I'm certainly no SET lover myself, but at least I know why people like them. And unlike you, I've sat around and listened carefully to positive and negative polarity distortion and I'm very aware of what it's characteristics sound like.

