So I use two preamps in various ways all the time (have four in the system at once), partly to have some volume control flexibility.
All that was to explain I use multiple volume gain and multiple equipment gain all the time.
In all my puttering around, I have found no magic combination, ever. More on one or another, maybe for ONE ALBUM, but usually it is always a tossup. The main problem is too much gain all around*. But I am not going to buy other equipment just to cure this.
* maybe if I played music at higher SPL, but I like it at lower levels.
What I would say is find out the zero gain point on the controls. Set one at that point. For example my Conrad Johnson ACT2 zero gain, attenuation is at ’77’ (out of 100) on the volume control. The zero gain/attenuation for my Bryston BP-26 is at 1 O’Clock on the volume knob (as it is set now, it can be changed, since it is just a set screw)See how it sounds with each in turn set to zero gain/attenuation. One combination may sound better than the other.

