Elizabeth, what is the silicon product you are polishing them with?
Is it possible that the slippery finish you feel is an artifact of modern CD production - something that may be removed with a little soap (natural, please) and warm water? I use my soapy fingers, as they are less likely to mark the soft polycarbonate than anything else, wiping in a radial manner; then rinse and pat dry.
I like Vivid; and I'm hearing good things about the new Auric Illuminator from a Vivid fan.
Regards,