2. speakers
  3. 1299724595

Zu Omens Vs Dali Vs Vandersteen Vs Sonus Faber


This post is FYI for those wondering about the quality of the Zu Omens (Don't worry, Be Happy and get them!):

At my personal recommendation, two friends here in Tucson bought Zu Omens, and one replaced her floor standing Dalis with the Omens and another replaced his Vandersteens with the Omens. He recommended them to two other friends here in Tucson who replaced their speakers with the Zu Omens. Once of the pairs replaced were Sonus Fabers.

I imagine that the Soul Superfly's are better of course.

BTW, I have Zu Druids. I am hesitant to replace them because I like them so much that I have painted them piano black and put granite bases on them. They bested (for my preferences of course for immediate rich sound) some Dynaudio, Dali, and Spendor floorstanders. However, I have not heard the Zu Omens and Druids in the same room. However, at another person's home the Omens sounded wonderful. Similar magical sound as the Druids with perhaps a little more bass and they are certainly less imposing in size (but not in quality) in the listening space. Hmmm, maybe I can get a pair of Omens and paint them piano black...
plangco
eniac26
95 posts
 
I would also be curious to hear more details about the quality of the ZU speakers and what they are capable of. I have to admit that based only on pictures alone I can't help but walk away leery on the use of the paper cones and whizzers. The drivers and their materials just dont "Look" capable of dishing out or taking a beating.

I think I would need to sit down and listen to them with a fist full of Paul Van Dyk Trance CD's played at a spirited volume to give these their fair shake and dispel any assumptions or fears I may have of their design.

Please dont take this as a knock on the brand or the speakers at all as I have not heard or seen them in person but only going on some detailed photos I looked at of the various models they offer. And I am well aware that looks can be very deceiving
mapman's avatar
mapman
15,679 posts
 
I've read some unconfirmed frequency response measurements on some Zu speakers in blogs (not always the most reliable source for these things and can't remember which Zus exactly, Druids perhaps, but not the newer models) that were not favorable at all from a flatness perspective. The full range drivers used were indicated as the culprit.

I do not know if this is the case or not, but such info is out there, so it would be helpful if someone could address it.

Maybe even if so that frequency response issues do not practically matter to the owners, though I think what I've seen would matter to me if I heard it. The benefits of teh full range driver approach in terms of coherency, soundstage and imaging, plus the high efficiency and synergy with tube amps could far outweigh any other issues.

After all, no speaker is perfect, especially those in the less expensive Zu's price range typically anyway.
charles1dad's avatar
charles1dad
6,996 posts
 
Treated paper drivers when done correctly can sound very natural and dynamic. I don`t own Zu speakers but one hugh advantage they have is high sensitivity and benign load characteristics. You are`nt forced to settle only for high power amps, but have the option to use high quality but low power amplifiers (SET,OTL,First Watt etc.) which can often sound better.
sebrof's avatar
sebrof
735 posts
 
03-11-11: Mapman
I've read some unconfirmed frequency response measurements on some Zu speakers in blogs (not always the most reliable source for these things and can't remember which Zus exactly, Druids perhaps, but not the newer models) that were not favorable at all from a flatness perspective. The full range drivers used were indicated as the culprit.<<

I did a little reaserch regarding this before I bought my Omens, and although not conclusive (it is the internet after all) I think this info may apply:
The Zu speakers in question were Druids, which are bottom porting. The floor gap/spacing is critical to get them to sound their best. The online mag that did the testing always hangs the speakers in mid air, I suppose to mitigate any boundry anomolies (floor, ceiling, walls).
But I didn't find anything to support this.
mapman's avatar
mapman
15,679 posts
 
Sebrof,

That could be.

FWIW, I looked at the specs for the new Omens. Zu indicates bandwidth in their specs but nothing regarding flatness of response that I could see.

I would expect getting flat response would be a challenge with most conventional full range drivers.

Plus specs can be overrated. Its what you hear and like that really matters.

Some people may care though, so it is worth taking note of these things.

There seems to be little risk with the Zu's however. I think they offer an audition period during which the speakers can be returned if not liked, right?
More to discover