Rrog, yes I disagreed with your premise, but did not make any comments about you. That is what an ad hominem argument is, when you don't agree with a person's premise, you attack the person, not the idea. No, I never said anything about you at all; I just disagreed with your conclusion. You took it to the personal level. And I believe that I was quite respectful in my disagreement.
Again, we can agree to disagree, I will let the posts speak to our relative character.
Again, we can agree to disagree, I will let the posts speak to our relative character.

