1. Home
  2. speakers
  3. 1412011197

Standmounts around 2k?

Yes, another "what would you recommend" thread. I've decided to take a more focused approach to building my system by first choosing speakers that fit my room and match my tastes. Amp matching will come after that. Here are the details: front end digital (Oppo or Marantz), listening room 13x15 (fairly live), play at low to moderate volumes (jazz, vocals, acoustic, some basic rock but not metal/hard rock). I'm very sensitive to excessive sibilance, and since I'm listening to digital I'm looking for a speaker on the darker side of neutral with a smooth tweeter. I currently have a floor stander (GE Triton 7) with a ribbon tweeter that is a bit too boomy in the bass and revealing/etched in the highs.

I'm looking for a stand mount that meets the above criteria around 2k or maybe a bit higher. The speakers in that range that have been suggested to me as meeting the criteria are:

a. LSA Statement 1
b. B&W CM5
c. Harbeth P3-esr
d. Nola Boxer
e. One of the Tekton Lores (a smaller floor stander)

Am I in the ballpark with these? I can't listen to them before buying, so ideally I would purchase from a dealer with a good return policy.

Thanks for any guidance,

Best, Scott
smrex13
smrex13 OP
423 posts
 
Yogiboy,

I am fascinated by Harbeth, and would love to have them in my system. My only question is whether the P3-esr is really too small (75hz is pretty minimal as far as bass depth). How did you find them to be? Did you go for the 7s because of something that the P3s lacked? I appreciate your thoughts.

Thanks,
Scott
worldwide
58 posts
 
Genelec 8250, Quested 2108, KH 310
yogiboy's avatar
yogiboy
2,678 posts
 
Hi Scott,
The only reason I bought the 7's was because I got them at a
great price,and I just hooked them up yesterday.
Now getting back to the 3's.
I never found them lacking in bass,as a matter of fact I am
finding that the bass is better than the larger ones,this
might be due to the sealed woofer on the P3's which I always
preferred to a ported type.
My room is 20x15 and I listen to the same type of music you
do.
I'm going to give it about two weeks of comparing both
speakers and then decide which ones I will keep.
I can't say enough more about the P3's,they are that good.
As a matter of fact my friend came up last year to give them
a listen and he replaced his Spendors with them.
Like I said,this is just my opinion,but I think you will not
go wrong with them and they work fine with my 50 watt amps.
Any other questions feel free to ask.
I just took a look at the listings and there are two new
pairs up for sale on this site,go for it!
Yogiboy
akg_ca's avatar
akg_ca
1,033 posts
 
ATC SCM 11 (2013)

What-HiFi review

"....Best standmounter £800-£1500, Awards 2013. ATC has struck gold again. These are the most talented standmounters anywhere near this price Tested at £1200...."

Read more at http://www.whathifi.com/atc/scm-11-2013/review#P6qre4lhiVIXjZ0w.99

Heard them at a dealer driven by both Naim and Mark Levinson - Totally stunned me just how good they were. All the store patrons gathered around for the audition, and one bought them on the spot.

Highly recommended .
smrex13 OP
423 posts
 
Thanks, Yogiboy. Your experience seems to mirror what I've read on various forums (the bass in the P3 is quite impressive and they don't need a ton of power). I recently bought a used Simaudio i-1 (50wpc 8ohms, 100wpc 4ohms), and I'm really impressed by it. It was just going to be a stopgap, but I don't see any need to upgrade it in the near future - very transparent, powerful, and non-faiguing. I think it will be a great match for the Harbeth P3esr. I'll let you know what I decide.

Thanks!
Scott
More to discover