Broadstone, your accounting is 100% in line with what I might expect having had a limited sampling of the various technologies and products mentioned, including Rogue Sphinx which I have rated quite highly in my current audio toys draft ratings.
Planars/ Electrostats benefits over box speakers?
I always been fascinated by Martin Logan and Magneplanar speakers. I have heard one or two models of both over the years. Would like to get some input from owners of "planar speakers" as what sound quality benefits do they offer over a floorstander, especially in the area of overall smoothness.
Are there any planar models of either company that have a small footprint and are not monolithic in height, but still sound very good???
Are there any planar models of either company that have a small footprint and are not monolithic in height, but still sound very good???
- ...
- 74 posts total
A summary of planar characteristics vs. dynamic box speakers is contained in this Absolute Sound review of the Maggie 20.7s under the heading, "Design Advantages of a Large Dipole Loudspeaker." I think this is a pretty good description that addresses the OP's original question. I found that his comments corroborate my own impressions of my 1.7s. |
An agenda, other than sharing my thoughts on this hobby? wow... on tunes, try buddy guy, done got old. You should hear his breath like he is hanging on your shoulder. You should feel the emotion coming over your shoulder lke a sledge hammer. My system is incrdedibly resolving. I had a pair of ohms back in 1982-84. Thy spent a year as front speakers, being relegatded to the rear channels shortly there after. Not a bad speaker but truly no where near the resolution of my stats. |
Cerrot ohms from early 80s would not likely do what you say. Those were the gen 1 models. I mentioned. The later revisions up to and including current x000 line are up to snuff in comparison to other very good modern speakers I hear. I had those originals for years along with other more modern designs to compare including the newer ohms. I've a/b Ed them side by side so I am confident with my assertions accordingly. |
- 74 posts total

