08-16-09: Jax2
Another friend (TVAD) thought his Esoteric X03 edged out the MWTP by a small margin in slightly superior resolution.
Just a couple small revisions. I own an Esoteric UX3-Pi, not an X-03. One is a universal player and the other is an SACD/CD player. To my knowledge, the SACD and CD audio sections of these players are identical. However, in the event that they aren't identical, I wanted to specify which player I own.
Also, in addition to better resolution, the Esoteric has better bass extension and definition, and the overall tonality is slightly better balanced. That said, the differences are slim, and by my percentage scale, the Esoteric is better by no more than 5%. Of course, my percentage could easily be someone else's 25%, so take it as you will.
Bottom line, the MW Transporter is outstanding.
The TP also adds the versatility of streaming various Internet music sources, like Pandora, and online radio stations.
Jax2 (Reviews | Threads | Answers)
This is how I have primarily been using my TP...as a streaming device for Pandora (the comparisons used to arrive at the conclusions regarding the TP vs. Esoteric were using redbook CDs with the Esoteric as a transport connected via its spdif digital output). In my home, for whatever reason...perhaps due to my wireless network (two Apple Airport Express devices), I have issues at times with the TP timing out and re-buffering.
I thought it's worth mentioning, as the wireless streaming is very nice to have, but the bugs are not worked out, IMO. Again, I am not laying blame on the TP, but the fact is that I don't know yet where the problem lies.