1. Home
  2. analog
  3. 1214871860

Cartridge downgrade?

I have been using a Shelter 90x with my SSM for several years happily but it's getting on in age and I've been contemplating what to replace it with when it's time. My table has been upgraded to reference status(super platter, mini feet, 10.5i arm, rim drive). I've thought about many of the likely suspects that might go with this combo(Lyra Titan vs. Skala, Shelter Harmony vs. 9000, Air Tight PC-1, Dynavector XV-1s) I wonder though if I'm just assuming these higher level cartridges are better than mid range ones. In particular, I wonder if I should try out VPI's version of the Dynavector 20x and save $3-4 thousand. Just wondered if anyone has tried a similar so called "down grade" and been happy. Is it possible that these high priced cartridges are overrated or a I just being cheap?
sonofjim
thom_mackris's avatar
thom_mackris
680 posts
 
Well ... maybe you know some of my preferences ;-)

I wish this forum software allowed you to edit your posts so I could be more clear on the "first" try.

What I meant to say was that while some of the carts on this short list may not be championed by me, in no way would I not strongly recommend them for consideration.

Different strokes and all that.

Cheers,
Thom @ Galibier
thomasheisig
568 posts
 
I think, the secret in Phono reproduction is the quality of the Phonostage and the Gain of it.
Most top cartridges are low output (around 0.22mV), when the preamp can't amplify that properly, frustration (and confusion) can be the result. Same with the connected Phono cable ....
To avoid that, there are cartridges with higher output available, for example the Lyra Skala.
When a combination is not really matched I think, a lower model can give better results (here low gain versus high gain/output etc.).
Next, some manufacturers change the sonic results in their models, here the Skala again for example, that one sounds very different to other Lyras.
I think, there is no general rule.
sonofjim OP
557 posts
 
Thanks to everyone for your input. This thread has opened my eyes to the Benz line of cartridges which I will have to give some consideration.
sonofjim OP
557 posts
 
Update,

I found a good deal on a Benz Ebony LP here on audiogon that hasn't been used or opened per seller's report. I'm sure I'll enjoy this cartridge and, again, thanks for your input.
thomasheisig
568 posts
 
Yes, the Benz LP is a real interesting choice, better than downgrading. These top Benz Systems can create a unique kind of magic when listening to voices, very special.
Have fun.
More to discover