Bob, to do what you want to do is a compromise, and you will have switches in the signal path before the RIAA EQ lifts the voltage of the signal, unless you use seperate phono preamps into seperate line level inputs in your preamp.
That said, if you choose to use swiching, keeping the wiring as short as possible, with the least amount of breaks, makes the most sense, and that generally calls for switching right at the input of the phono preamp. You still will have the switch contacts and the short lengths of wire, but at least you don't have the breaks and cable effects of additional interconnects and their added capacitance as well as the overall longer signal path.
That said, if you choose to use swiching, keeping the wiring as short as possible, with the least amount of breaks, makes the most sense, and that generally calls for switching right at the input of the phono preamp. You still will have the switch contacts and the short lengths of wire, but at least you don't have the breaks and cable effects of additional interconnects and their added capacitance as well as the overall longer signal path.

