Arthur: Those are very good points and well worth clarifying. Thanks for taking the time to point them out AND explain them.
I have often said that it is the sum of manufacturer spec's that count more than any individual spec by itself. Even then, most manufacturers don't provide the quantity of spec's that one needs to make such information truly useful.
As to your comment about most amps having a linear output impedance up to appr 50 KHz, that is kind of generous in my experience. Many amps exhibit a noticeable increase in output impedance at or slightly above 10 KHz. How severe this is will depend on the design of the amp. By 50 KHz - 80 KHz or so, performance is starting to suffer quite noticeably. This is why many amps round the leading edge of a 10 KHz square wave. That is, the higher output impedance is part of a bigger problem i.e. limited bandwidth due to the amp being too slow to properly respond. Combine the limited bandwidth / lack of speed with the rising output impedance and you end up with that slightly rounded square wave that you see so often in Stereophile test measurements.
If you think that this sounds "bad", there are REALLY slow / limited bandwidth / higher output impedance amps fail the 1 KHz square wave test. When this type of amp encounters a very fast high energy high frequency transient, most of the attack, definition and duration is lost. This translates into a soft sounding blur, which some people like. This is probably more true with digital recordings and playback, which tends to sound hard, bright and glaring in many systems.
Other than that, this thread could go on and on contrasting various designs and goals. Suffice it to say that there are a LOT of variations that come into play with any / every design. When all is said and done though, the end result is a summary of what the designer / engineer thought was most important. Whether or not you like that product will depend on your own personal preferences and how well that specific component blends with the other gear in your system. As far as i know, there are no spec's to quantify personal preference. Sean
>
I have often said that it is the sum of manufacturer spec's that count more than any individual spec by itself. Even then, most manufacturers don't provide the quantity of spec's that one needs to make such information truly useful.
As to your comment about most amps having a linear output impedance up to appr 50 KHz, that is kind of generous in my experience. Many amps exhibit a noticeable increase in output impedance at or slightly above 10 KHz. How severe this is will depend on the design of the amp. By 50 KHz - 80 KHz or so, performance is starting to suffer quite noticeably. This is why many amps round the leading edge of a 10 KHz square wave. That is, the higher output impedance is part of a bigger problem i.e. limited bandwidth due to the amp being too slow to properly respond. Combine the limited bandwidth / lack of speed with the rising output impedance and you end up with that slightly rounded square wave that you see so often in Stereophile test measurements.
If you think that this sounds "bad", there are REALLY slow / limited bandwidth / higher output impedance amps fail the 1 KHz square wave test. When this type of amp encounters a very fast high energy high frequency transient, most of the attack, definition and duration is lost. This translates into a soft sounding blur, which some people like. This is probably more true with digital recordings and playback, which tends to sound hard, bright and glaring in many systems.
Other than that, this thread could go on and on contrasting various designs and goals. Suffice it to say that there are a LOT of variations that come into play with any / every design. When all is said and done though, the end result is a summary of what the designer / engineer thought was most important. Whether or not you like that product will depend on your own personal preferences and how well that specific component blends with the other gear in your system. As far as i know, there are no spec's to quantify personal preference. Sean
>