I would possibly suspect 'a' previous owner blew one side out, rewired it to run both speakers off the one working side. and then passed it off as a working amp.
So you have half an amp doing the job of both.
Whomever sold it to you perhaps? never knew it is messed up. Your best choice is to return it while you can. If you cannot return it. i would think it will cost you as much or more to fix it, than to find another used one.
Next time make certain you have a recourse, if you are stuck with a lemon. You may feel you want to 'save' your purchase, but if you can return it, do so. It is not as advertised, and if they only guaranteed to be not DOA, it IS DOA, in one channel. If it was sold "as is", then i think you have a partially useful doorstop.
This is, of course only a guess as to what the problem is. Since only paying someone $100. just to look at it, and is not even a start at actually fixing it...
Sorry.