Current amp vs Voltage amp

Al,
As always I appreciate your patient and clear explanations. What you eloquently describe is born out with simply listening. Either tube or SS amplifiers will be the best choice depending on the particular driven speaker's design characteristics. Just listen. There's no universal one fits all amplifier design that exists. It all begins with the intentions of the speaker designer.
Best Regards,

@ Almarg,, Thankyou so much!, That was very good of you to put an explanation in a very good context!your educated facts is an asset to us all!, you are absolutly correct!,,Happy listening!

Frequency response flatness at the amplifier output/speaker input has no direct relevance. Speakers whose impedance varies significantly as a function of frequency, and that match most optimally with tube amps, can be presumed to require a non-flat frequency response at their input terminals to produce an acoustic output whose frequency response is flat. If such a speaker is mated with a solid state amplifier having near zero output impedance, frequency response flatness will have been optimized at the output of the amplifier, but it will be wrong at the output of the speaker.

hi Al, often it seems that a speaker manuf tries to find an amplifier that has an approximate H^-1(f) transfer function of that manuf's speaker so that the amplifier input-to-speaker output (which is sound) transfer function is more or less flat over the audio bandwidth.
As you would agree this is a very limiting way to design a speaker - change the amp (or another variable) & the performance falls off the cliff....

Hi Bombaywalla,

Yes, agreed.

As you certainly realize, any design involves a zillion or so tradeoffs and competing considerations, but it's still striking how some speakers can perform well with very diverse kinds of amplifiers, while other speakers cause the choice of amplifier to be very critical.

One of the reasons I chose the Daedalus speakers I have is that their combination of a pretty much flat impedance curve, high efficiency, and high power handling capability makes them suitable for use with just about any amplifier out there, except for the really flea-powered types. The Coincidents that Charles uses are similar in that respect.

Charles & Audiolabyrinth, thank you most kindly for the nice words.

Best regards,
-- Al

One of the reasons I chose the Daedalus speakers I have is that their combination of a pretty much flat impedance curve, high efficiency, and high power handling capability makes them suitable for use with just about any amplifier out there...

indeed good qualifications for a speaker to have. Empirically you will find that the people obsessing the least about amplifier-speaker interface are those that have understood the need for the speaker to have a relatively flat impedance & phase (let's not forget that phase response!) curves vs. frequency. Often in these speakers the curve is -3dB at 20KHz which I have been told by certain speaker manufs that this provides better in-room acoustics (vs. a speaker that has no turn-down at 20KHz). Such flat impedance speakers speak about the manuf ability to understand playback requirements & the ability to produce a product that is largely agnostic of the amplifier. Few such speaker manuf exist.....
I heard the Daedalus at RMAF one year - I remember that their sonics were very good. Best regards.