Well, I received the 1 1/2" arch punch today, and it's absolutely perfect for the job. Thanks, Stilljd, for the suggestion.
I have a few extra sets of four 1 1/2", 3/8" (not 5/8" as previously stated), 40 durometer discs available for a very reasonable price.
I have a few extra sets of four 1 1/2", 3/8" (not 5/8" as previously stated), 40 durometer discs available for a very reasonable price.

